Abstract
Santali presents structures with subject clitics in “P minus 2” (P-2) position, before the final verb and
enclitic on the preverbal element, a position called “Backernagel” by Kidwai (2005). P-2 is commonly
considered to lack clear cross-linguistic support; moreover, while generative accounts can accommodate
utterance-second position (P2) as adjunction to a left-peripheral projection, they have no ready way
of accommodating P -2.
The history and synchrony of Munda “P-2” have elicited several accounts. Anderson (2007) considers
three possibilities: Reanalysis of P roto-Munda subject proclitics as enclitic; extension of postverbal
object clitics to preverbal subject function; attachment of original resumptive pronouns to the preverbal
element.
I present evidence for a different hypothesis: T he Santali Backernagel clitics originate as P 2 or classical
W ackernagel elements. A more fine-grained definition of W ackernagel in terms of different prosodic
domains (such as utterance/theme vs. rheme) permits the hypothesis that the apparent P -2 is still
a W ackernagel position, but within the rheme rather than the entire utterance, and that within the rheme,
the prosodically strongest, preverbal-focus element is the most attractive clitic host.
I support my account with evidence from Santali and other K herwarian languages (which offer traces of
an original P 2 position) and parallel developments in Iranian (where the different stages in the development
can be traced in greater detail).
Backernagel, thus, is a subtype of W ackernagel, and there is no need to assume a typologically problematic
P -2 position for Munda (or for various Iranian varieties).
References
Anderson Gregory D.S. 2007. The Munda Verb: Typological Perspectives. Berlin-New York: Mouton de Gruyter.
Anderson Gregory D.S. (ed.). 2008. The Munda Languages. L ondon-New York: Routledge.
Bubenik Vit, Luraghi Silvia. 2010. Continuum Companion to Historical Linguistics. London-New York: Continuum Books.
Cysouw Michael. 2004. “The Rise of P erson Inflection with Special Reference to the Munda L anguages.” In: 11th International Morphology Meeting, Vienna, http://email.eva.mpg.de/~cysouw/pdf/cysouwMUN-DA.pdf.
Durkin-Meisterernst Desmond. 2009. “Khwarezmian.” In: Windfuhr 2009: 336-376.
Dutta Indranil, Hock H ans H enrich. 2006. “Interaction of Verb A ccentuation and U tterance Finality in Bangla.” In: Hoffmann & Mixdorff 2006.
Emerick Ronald E . 2009. “Khotanese and T umshuqese.” In: Windfuhr 2009: 377-415.
Erschler David. 2009. “Modularity and 2P Clitics: A rguments from Digor O ssetic.” In: Proceedings of IATL 25 [Israel A ssociation for Theoretical L inguistics], http://linguistics.huji.ac.il/IATL/25/Erschler.pdf.
Ghosh Arun. 2008. “Santali.” In: Anderson 2008: 11-98.
Goldberg Adele. 1996. “Words by Default: O ptimizing Constraints and the P ersian Complex P redicate.” In: Proceedings of the 1996 Berkeley Linguistic Society Meeting, 132-146.
Grierson George A . 1906. Linguistic Survey of India. Vol. 4: Munda & Dravidian Languages. Calcutta: The Government P rinting O ffices.
Haig Geoffrey L .J. 2008. Alignment Change in Iranian Languages: A Construction Grammar Approach. Berlin- New York: Mouton de Gruyter.
Halpern Aaron, Zwicky Arnold (eds.) 1996. Approaching Second: Second Position Clitics and Related Phenomena. Stanford: CSLI P ublications.
Hammond M. et al. (eds.). 1988. Studies in Syntactic Typology. Amsterdam-Philadelphia: Benjamins.
Harlig Jeffrey, Bardovi-Harlig K athleen. 1988. “Accentuation T ypology, W ord O rder, and T heme-rheme Structure.” In: Hammond et al. 1988: 125-146.
Hayes Bruce, Lahiri A diti. 1991. “Bengali Intonational P honology.” Natural Language and Linguistic Theory 9, 47-96.
Hock Hans Henrich. 1996. “Who’s O n First: T oward a P rosodic A ccount of P 2 Clitics.” In: Halpern & Zwicky 1996: 199-270.
Hock Hans Henrich. 2010. “Typology and U niversals.” In: Bubenik & Luraghi 2010: 56-69.
Hoffmann Rüdiger, Mixdorff H ansjörg. 2006. CD-ROM Proceedings of Speech Prosody: 3rd International Conference, Dresden, May 2-5, 2006. (Studientexte zur Sprachkommunikation, 40.) Dresden: U D press.
Jahani Carina, Korn A gnes. 2009. “Balochi.” In: Windfuhr 2009: 634-692.
Kidwai Ayesha. 2005. “Santali ‘Backernagel’ Clitics: Distributing Clitic Doubling.” In: Singh 2005: 189-207.
Kieffer Charles M. 2009. “Parachi.” In: Windfuhr 2009: 693-720.
Kim A .H. 1988. “Preverbal Focusing and T ype XXIII L anguages.” In: Hammond et al. 1988: 147-169.
Kobayashi Masato, Murmu G anesh. 2008. “Keraʔ Mundari.” In: Anderson 2008: 165-194.
Ladd D. Robert. 1980. The Structure of Intonational Meaning: Evidence from English. Bloomington-London: Indiana University Press.
Ladd D. Robert. 1996. Intonational Phonology. Cambridge: Cambridge U niversity P ress.
Osada Toshiki. 2008. “Mundari.” In: Anderson 2008: 99-164.
Radanović-Kocić Vesna. 1988. The Grammar of Serbo-Croatian Clitics: A Synchronic and Diachronic Perspective. Urbana: U niversity of Illinois P h.D. dissertation in L inguistics.
Radanović-Kocić Vesna. 1996. “The P lacement of Serbo-Croatian Clitics: A P rosodic A pproach.” In: Halpern & Zwicky 1996: 429-445.
Singh Rajendra (ed.). 2005. The Yearbook of South Asian Languages and Linguistics (2005). Berlin-New York: Mouton de Gruyter.
Skjærvø Prods O ktor. 2009a. “Old Iranian.” In: Windfuhr 2009: 43-195.
Skjærvø Prods O ktor. 2009b. “Middle W est Iranian.” In: Windfuhr 2009: 196-278.
Tegey Habibullah. 1977. The Grammar of Clitics: Evidence from Pashto and Other Languages. Urbana: University of Illinois P h.D. dissertation in L inguistics. [Published also by the International Center for P ashto Studies, K abul, apparently with unchanged pagination.] Windfuhr Gernot (ed.). 2009. The Iranian Languages. L ondon-New York: Routledge.
Windfuhr Gernot, Perry J ohn R. 2009. “Persian and T ajik.” In: Windfuhr 2009: 416-544.
Yoshida Yutaka. 2009. “Sogdian.” In: Windfuhr 2009: 279-335.
License
Copyright (c) 2013 Hans Henrich Hock
![Creative Commons License](http://i.creativecommons.org/l/by-nc-nd/4.0/88x31.png)
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.