The Self and Agency in History. Some Remarks in Defense of Classical Historiography
Journal cover Sensus Historiae, volume 15, no. 2, year 2014, title O myśleniu historycznym raz jeszcze
PDF (Język Polski)

Keywords

metaphor
moral notions
historical writing
classical historiography
non-classical historiography
agency
Wojciech Wrzosek

How to Cite

Weiss, M. (2014). The Self and Agency in History. Some Remarks in Defense of Classical Historiography. Sensus Historiae, 15(2), 21–34. https://doi.org/10.14746/sh.2014.15.2.002

Number of views: 0


Number of downloads: 0

Abstract

In his insightful works regarding state of contemporary historiography professor Wojciech Wrzosek diff erentiates between classical and non-classical historiography. In this text I discuss above-mentioned opposition in the context of moral philosophy, especially such notions as moral self, moral agency and moral responsibility. My thesis is that a classical historiography is based on metaphors thanks to what we are capable of being moral agents, i. e. we are able to make moral judgments and hold other people responsible for their actions; acting with reference to right and wrong and taking responsibility for these actions as well. On the contrary, nonclassical historiography refers to metaphors that undermines traditional moral notions, particulary individual agency. Th erefore, if we want to treat ourselves as moral agents, then we cannot reject traditional historical writing.

https://doi.org/10.14746/sh.2014.15.2.002
PDF (Język Polski)