Keywords
mixture
elemental theory
Hippocratic Corpus
De victu
De generatione et corruptione
How to Cite
Abstract
Aristotle’s notion of qualitative interaction ruling both the process of mixture and the process of reciprocal elemental transmutation is based upon the idea of a physical contrariety endowed with two extremes and a wide central area where the opposite forces reach different equilibrium points (i.e., the so-called mixtures) or can be present to the fullest degree (in this case we do not have a mixture, but an element). Differently from previous scholarship which attributes this notion specifically to Aristotle, we have found, in a text which Aristotle seems to have been acquainted with, the Hippocratic De victu, an incipient structure of a contrariety endowed with extremes and a central area where opposite forces meet and yield respective equilibrium points, mixtures, which, as in Aristotle, give an account of the variety of beings existing in the world. In this article, we suggest the possibility that in the development of the Aristotelian thinking about elemental and qualitative dynamics, the Hippocratic De victu may have contributed to suggesting to Aristotle a way of envisioning the structure of his basic physical contrarieties.
References
Althoff, J., 1992, Warm, kalt, flüssig und fest bei Aristoteles, Stuttgart.
Bartoš, H., 2015, Philosophy and Dietetics in the Hippocratic On Regimen. A delicate balance of Health, Leidein—Boston.
Bogen, J., 1992, “Change and Contrariety in Aristotle”, Phronesis 37 (1), pp. 1–21.
Brunschwig, J., 2004, “On Generation and Corruption I.1: a false start?”, in: De Haas, Mansfeld (2004), pp. 25–63.
Caston, V. (transl.), 2012, Alexander of Aphrodisias, On the Soul: Part I, London.
Crowley, T. J., 2008, “Aristotle’s so-called elements”, Phronesis 53 (3), pp. 223–242.
Crowley, T. J., 2013, “De generatione et corruptione 2.3: Does Aristotle identify the contraries as elements?”, Classical Quarterly 63 (1), pp. 161–182.
De Haas, F., Mansfeld, J., 2004, Aristotle: On Generation and Corruption, Book I. Symposium aristotelicum, Oxford.
Frede, D., 2004, “On Generation and Corruption I.10: On mixture and mixable”, in: De Haas and Mansfeld (2004), pp. 289–314.
Giardina, G. R. (transl.), 2008a, Aristotele, Sulla generazione e la corruzione, Roma.
Giardina, G. R., 2008b, La Chimica Fisica di Aristotele. Teoria degli elementi e delle loro proprietà. Analisi critica del De generatione et corruptione, Roma.
Gill, M. L., 1989, Aristotle on Substance: the Paradox of Unity, Princeton.
Grimaudo, S., 2008, Difendere la salute. Igiene e disciplina del soggetto nel De sanitate tuenda di Galeno, Napoli.
Groisard, J., 2016, Mixis. Le problème du mélange dans la philosophie grecque d’Aristote à Simplicius, Paris.
Joachim, H. H., 1904, “Aristotle’s conception of chemical combination”, Journal of Philology 29, pp. 72–86.
Joachim, H. H., 1922, Aristotle. On coming to be and passing away. A revised text with introduction and commentary by Harold H. Joachim, Oxford.
Joly, R. (tralnsl.), 2003, Hippocratis, De diaeta, edidit, in linguam Francogallicam vertit, commentatus est R. Joly adiuvante S. Byl, CMG I 2, 4 editio altera lucis ope expressa addendis et corrigendis aucta curatis a S. Byl, Berlin.
Jones, W. H. S. (transl.), 1959, Hippocrates with an English Translation by W. H. S. Jones. Vol. IV, London—Cambridge.
Jouanna, J., 1999, Hippocrates, transl. M. B. DeBevoise, Baltimore—London [originally published as Hippocrate, Paris 1992].
Jouanna, J. (transl.), 2002, Hippocratis De natura hominis, edidit, in linguam Francogallicam vertit, commentatus est J. Jouanna, CMG I 1,3, editio altera lucis ope expressa addendis et corrigendis aucta, Berlin.
Jouanna, J., 2012, “The Legacy of the Hippocratic Treatise The Nature of Man: The Theory of the Four Humours”, in: J. Jouanna, Greek Medicine from Hippocrates to Galen. Selected Papers, transl. N. Allies, P. van der Eijk (ed.), Leiden—Boston, pp. 335–359.
Krizan, M., 2013, “Elemental structure and the trasformations of the elements in On generation and corruption II.4”, Oxford Studies in ancient Philosophy 45, pp. 195–224.
Krizan, M., 2018a, “Mixture and the Formation of Homoeomers in On Generation and Corruption 2.7”, Oxford Studies in ancient Philosophy 54, pp. 187–226.
Krizan, M., 2018b, “Primary Qualities and Aristotle’s Elements”, Ancient Philosophy 38 (1), pp. 91–112.
Kullmann, W., 1982, “Aristoteles‘ Grundgedanken zu Aufbau und Funktion der Körpergewebe“, Sudhoffs Archiv 66 (3), pp. 209–238.
Lennox J. G. (transl.), 2001, Aristotle, On the parts of animals, Oxford.
Lloyd, G. E. R., 1964, “The Hot and the Cold, the Dry and the Wet in Greek Philosophy”, Journal of Hellenic Studies 84, pp. 92–106.
Longrigg, J., 1993, Greek Rational Medicine. Philosophy and Medicine from Alcmaeon to the Alexandrians, London—New York.
Mansfeld, J., 1983, “Zeno and Aristotle on Mixture”, Mnemosyne 36 (3–4), pp. 306–310.
Migliori, M. (transl.), 2013, Aristotele, La generazione e la corruzione, Milano [revised version of M. Migliori, Aristotele, La generazione e la corruzione. Traduzione, introduzione e commento, Napoli 1976].
Miller, H. W., 1959, “The concept of dynamis in De victu”, Transactions of the American Philological Association 90, pp. 184–197.
Mirrione, C., 2017, Theory and Terminology of Mixture in Galen. The Concepts of krasis and mixis in Galen’s
Thought, Dissertation zur Erlangung des akademischen Grades Dr. phil. eingereicht an der Philosophischen Fakultät II der Humboldt—Universität zu Berlin, Berlin.
Mourelatos, A. P. D., 1984., “Aristotle’s rationalist account of qualitative interaction“, Phronesis 29 (1), pp. 1–16.
Plamböck, G., 1964, “Dynamis im Corpus Hippocraticum“, Akademie der Wissenschaften und der Literatur,
Mainz. Abhandlungen der Geistes- und Sozialwissenschaftlichen Klasse 2, pp. 58–111.
Popa, T., 2014, “Observing the Invisible. Regimen I on Elemental Powers and Higher Order Dispositions”, British Journal for the History of Philosophy 22 (5), pp. 888–907.
Rashed, M. (transl.), 2005, Aristote, De la génération et la corruption, Paris.
Van der Eijk, P., 2005, Medicine and Philosophy in Classical Antiquity. Doctors and Philosophers on Nature, Soul, Health and Disease, Cambridge.
Vizgin, V. P., 1980, “Hippocratic Medicine as a Historical Source for Aristotle’s Theory of the Dynameis”, Studies in History of Medicine 4, pp. 1–12.
Williams C. J. F. (transl.), 1982, Aristotle’s De generatione et corruptione, Oxford.
Zarifian, A., 2018, “Mescolanza e trasformazione nel De generatione et corruptione di Aristotele”, Peitho. Examina antiqua 9 (1), pp. 53–69.
License
Peitho provides immediate open access to its content on the principle that making research freely available to the public supports a greater global exchange of knowledge.