ΠΑΙΣ ΠΑΙΖΩΝ. Homer, Iliad XV 362–364, Heraclitus, DK 22 B 52, and F. Nietzsche
PDF

Keywords

Nietzsche
Heraclitus
construction and annihilation
children’s games

How to Cite

Pòrtulas, J. (2024) “ΠΑΙΣ ΠΑΙΖΩΝ. Homer, Iliad XV 362–364, Heraclitus, DK 22 B 52, and F. Nietzsche”, Peitho. Examina Antiqua, 15(1), pp. 397–416. doi: 10.14746/pea.2024.1.22.

Abstract

Friedrich Nietzsche resorted several times to the image of a child playing with sand or pebbles. His purpose in doing so was to evoke a cyclical process of construction and destruction devoid of both responsibility and finality. This essay examines, on the one hand, the relation of the child’s image to its two main hypotexts (Heraclitus DK 22 B 52 and Iliad XV 362-64) and, on the other, the range of Nietzsche’s uses of the simile.

https://doi.org/10.14746/pea.2024.1.22
PDF

References

Babut, D., 1976, “Héraclite, critique des poètes et des savants,” AC 45, pp. 464–496.

Barbera, S., 1992, “Apollineo e Dionisiaco. Alcune fonti non antiche di Nietzsche,” in: Campioni, Venturelli (1992), pp. 45–70.

Bernays, J., 1850, “Heraklitische Studien,” Rheinisches Museum 7, pp. 90–116.

Bernays, J., 1869, Die heraklitischen Briefe. Ein Beitrag zur philosophischen und religionsgeschichtlichen Literatur, Berlin.

Bernays, J., 1885 Gesammelte Abhandlungen, H. Usener (hrsg.), vol. I–II, Berlin.

Bouvier, D., Dasen V. (eds.), 2020, Héraclite: Le temps est un enfant qui joue, Liège.

Campioni G., Venturelli, A. (cur.), 1992, La ‘Biblioteca ideale’ di Nietzsche, Napoli.

Colli, G. (trad.), (1973), F. Nietzsche, La filosofia nell’epoca tragica dei greci e Scritti dal 1870 al 1873, Milano.

Conche, M. (ed.), 1986, Héraclite, Fragments, Paris.

Degani, E., 20012, ΑΙΩΝ, Bologna (1ª ed. Padova 1961).

De Launay, M. et al. (trad.), 2000, F. Nietzsche, Œuvres I. La naissance de la tragédie. Considerations inactuelles, Paris.

Diano, C., Serra, G. (cur.), 1980, Eraclito, I frammenti e le testimonianze, Milano.

D’Iorio, P., 2011, “L’image des philosophes préplatoniciens chez le jeune Nietzsche,” in: Venturelli, Gerratana, Borsche 2011, pp. 383–417.

D’Iorio, P., Fronterotta, F. (eds.), 1994, F. Nietzsche, Les philosophes préplatoniciens suivi de les διαδοχαί des philosophes, Paris.

Diels, H., Kranz, W. (hrsg.), 1952, Die Fragmente der Vorsokratiker, Zürich (Unveränderter Nachdruck 1996).

Ferrer, D.F., 2020, Nietzche’s Seven Notebooks from 1876. Translations and Illuminations (https://philpapers.org/versions/).

Finkelberg, A., 2009, “The Cosmic Cycle, a Playing Child and the Rules of the Game,” in: Hülsz Piccone 2009, pp. 315–336.

Fornari, G. (cur.), 2012, Eraclito: la luce dell’Oscuro, Firenze.

Fraenkel, H., 1975, Early Greek Poetry and Philosophy, transl. M. Hadas, J. Willis, Oxford.

Fraenkel, H., 1977, Die homerischen Gleichnisse, Göttingen (Erste Ausgabe, 1921).

Fronterotta, F. (cur.), 2013, Eraclito, Frammenti, Milano.

García Calvo. A., 1985, Razón Común. Edición crítica, ordenación, traducción y comentario de los restos del libro de Heraclito, Madrid.

Gay, P., Kaufmann, W., 1967, Basic Writings of Nietzsche, New York.

Genovés Company, R., 2015, El recurso a Heráclito en la obra de Friedrich Nietzsche, Tesis doctoral inédita. Universitat de les Illes Balears. (https://dspace.uib.es/xmlui/handle/11201/149169).

Glucker, J., Laks, A. (eds.), 1996, Jacob Bernays. Un philologue juif, Lille.

Griffin, J., 1980, Homer on Life and Death, Oxford.

Gritti, E., 2012, “Il testo eracliteo: breve storia di una riscoperta,” in: Fornari 2012, pp. 267–288.

Halliwell, S., 2018, “Justifying the World as an Aesthetic Phenomenon,” Cambridge Classical Journal 44, pp. 91–112.

Hershbell, J.P., Nimis, S.A., 1979, “Nietzsche and Heraclitus,” Nietzsche – Studien 8, pp. 17–38.

Hülsz Piccone, E. (ed.), 2009, Nuevos Ensayos sobre Heráclito, México.

Hülsz Piccone, E., 2011, LÓGOS: Heráclito y los orígenes de la filosofía, México.

Kahn, C.H., 1979, The Art and Thought of Heraclitus, Cambridge.

Kaufmann, W., 1954, The Portable Nietzsche, New York–London.

Kirk, G.S. (ed.), 1954, Heraclitus, The Cosmic Fragments, Cambridge.

Kurke, L., 1999, Coins, Bodies, Games, and Gold. The Politics of Meaning in Archaic Greece, Princeton.

Laks, A., Most, G.W. (eds.), 2016, Early Greek Philosophy III. Early Ionian Thinkers 2. Cambridge–London.

Lloyd-Jones, H., 1976, “Nietzsche and the Study of the Ancient World,” in: O’Flaherty, Sellner, Helm 1976, pp. 1–15.

Marcovich, M. (ed.), 1967, Heraclitus. Greek Text with a Short Commentary, Mérida (Venezuela).

Momigliano, A., 2016, “Jacob Bernays,” in: A. Momigliano, Pagine ebraiche, S. Berti (cur.), Roma.

Mondolfo, R., 1971, Heráclito. Textos y problemas de su interpretación, México.

Moroney, P., 1986, Nietzsche’s Dionysian Aristocratic Culture, Maynooth.

Mouraviev, S., 2000, Heraclitea II.A.2. Traditio (A). A Seneca usque ad Diogenem Laertium, Sankt Augustin.

Mouraviev, S., 2006, Heraclitea III.3.B/iii. Fragmenta. Ad lectiones adnotamenta, Sankt Augustin.

Newcomb, T., 2024, Philosophy in the Tragic Age of the Greeks, Livraria Press. https://www.newcomblivrariapress.com/

O’Flaherty, J.C., Sellner, T.F., Helm R.M. (eds.), 1976, Studies in Nietzsche and the Classical Tradition, Chapel Hill.

Onians, R.B., 1951, The Origins of European Thought about the Body, the Mind, the Soul, the World, Time, and Fate, Cambridge (Reprint 1988).

Otto, W.F., 1954, The Homeric Gods. The Spiritual Significance of Greek Religion, transl. M. Hadas, New York (German edition, Frankfurt 1929).

Porter, J.I., 2000, The Invention of Dionysus. An Essay on The Birth of Tragedy, Stanford.

Pòrtulas, J., 1993, “Heráclito y los maîtres à penser de su tiempo,” Emerita 61, pp. 159–176.

Pòrtulas, J., (forthcoming), Omero, Iliade, vol. IV: Libri XIII–XVI, Milano.

Pradeau, J.-F. (ed.), 2002, Héraclite, Fragments [Citations et témoignages], Paris.

Rayman, J., 2023, “Nietzsche’s Heraclitus: Historical Figure and Personal-Philosophical Archetype,” Nietzsche – Studien 52, pp. 40–76.

Sánchez Meca, D. et al. (ed.), 2011 (20162), F. Nietzsche, Obras completas I. Escritos de juventud, Madrid.

Santiago Guervós, L.E. de (trad.), 2007, F. Nietzsche, Fragmentos póstumos I (1869–1874), Madrid.

Schädler, U., 2009, “ 'Pente grammai' – The Ancient Greek Board Game Five Lines”, in: Silva 2009, pp. 173–196.

Schädler, U., 2020, “ 'Le temps est un enfant qui joue' – mais à quoi? La perspective ludographique”, in: Bouvier, Dasen 2020, pp. 147-157.

Schleiermacher, L., 1808, “Herakleitos der dunkle, von Ephesos, dargestellt aus den Trümmern seines Werkes und den Zeugnissen der Alten,” Museum der Alterthums-Wissenschaft 1, pp. 313–533.

Silk, M. S., Stern, J. P., 1981, Nietzsche on Tragedy, Cambridge.

Silva, J.-P. (ed.), 2009, Proceedings of the Board Game Studies Colloquium XI , Lisboa.

Ugolini, G., 2007, Guida alla lettura della ‘Nascita della Tragedia’ di Nietzsche, Roma–Bari.

Venturelli, A., Gerratana, F., Borsche T. (eds.), 2011, Centauren-Geburten. Wissenschaft, Kunst und Philosophie beim jungen Nietzsche, Berlin–Boston.

West, M.L., 1971, Early Greek Philosophy and the Orient, Oxford.

Whitlock, G. (transl.), 2001 (20062), F. Nietzsche, The Pre-Platonic Philosophers, Urbana–Chicago.

Whitman, J., 1986, “Nietzsche in the Magisterial Tradition of German Classical Philology,” Journal of the History of Ideas 47, pp. 453–468.