Keywords
myth
origins of human society
Plato
poetry
Protagoras
punishment
παιδεία
πόλις
How to Cite
Abstract
The great speech of the Protagoras (320c–328d) still leaves many questions open. Particularly striking is the presence of doctrines that later on will be taken up and further developed by Plato in such dialogues as the Politicus, the Timaeus and the Laws. For this reason, many scholars tend to think that the words of Protagoras are just a product of Plato’s invention that bear no relation to Protagoras’ actual doctrines. Nevertheless, it is possible to propose a different interpretation. At the beginning of the Protagoras (313a–314b), Socrates develops the image of the sophist as the merchant of various μαθήματα: to sell his products, the sophist praises them all indiscriminately without knowing which of them are useful and which are harmful. But he who has the ability to make this distinction can still purchase the μαθήματα from Protagoras or anyone else. Through the dialectic, Plato is able to examine them without any danger in the Protagoras and then take them up and further develop in new ways in his later dialogues.
References
Arrighetti, G., 2008, “Cameleonte peripatetico e gli studi sulla biografia greca”, in: P. Arduini, S. Audano, A. Borghini, A. Cavarzere, G. Mazzoli, G. Paduano, A. Russo (eds.), Studi offerti ad Alessandro Perutelli, I, Roma, pp. 63–69.
Arrighetti, G., 2013, “Il Protagora platonico, Esiodo e la genesi dell’uomo”, Athenaeum 101, pp. 25–42.
Beresford, A., 2013, “Fangs, Feathers, & Fairness: Protagoras on the Origins of Right and Wrong”, in: M. Van Raalte, J. van Ophuijsen, P. Stork (eds.), Protagoras of Abdera. The Man, His Measure, Leiden-New York, pp. 139–162.
Bertagna, M. I., 2012, “Sulla costruzione del racconto nel Protagora di Platone”, Antiquorum Philosophia 6, pp. 91–100.
Bonazzi, M., 2009, “Protagoras d’Abdère”, in: J.-F. Pradeau (ed.), Les Sophistes, I, Paris, pp. 45-90 e 443–472.
Bonazzi, M., 2010, I sofisti, Roma.
Bonazzi, M., 2012, “Il mito di Prometeo nel Protagora: una variazione sul tema delle origini”, in: F. Calabi, S. Gastaldi (eds.), Immagini delle origini. La nascita della civiltà e della cultura nel pensiero greco e romano, Sankt Augustin, pp. 41–57.
Boys-Stone, G. R., 2010, “Hesiod and Plato’s History of Philosophy”, in: G. R. Boys-Stone, J. H. Haubold (eds.), Plato and Hesiod, Oxford-New York, pp. 31–51.
Brancacci, A., 2002, “Protagora e la techne sophistike. Plat. Prot. 316 D-317 C, Elenchos 23, pp. 11–32.
Brancacci, A., 2012, “La pensée politique de Protagoras”, Revue de Philosophie Ancienne 30, pp. 59–85.
Brisson, L., 2004, “La Repubblica specchio del Protagora. La lista di virtù necessarie al buon funzionamento della città”, in: G. Casertano (ed.), Il Protagora di Platone: struttura e problematiche, Napoli, pp. 317–327.
Brisson, L., 2012, “Why Is the Timaeus Called an Eikôs Muthos and an Eikôs Logos?”, in: C. Collobert, P. Destrée, F. J. Gonzalez (eds.), Plato and Myth. Studies on the Use and Status of Platonic Myths, Leiden- Boston, pp. 369–391.
Burnyeat, M. F., 2005 (2009), “Eikōs muthos”, Rhizai 2, pp. 143-165, ora in: C. Partenie (ed.), Plato’s Myths, Cambridge-New York, pp. 167–186.
Calame, C., 2012, “The Pragmatics of ‘Myth’ in Plato’s Dialogues: The Story of Prometheus in the Protagoras”, in: C. Collobert, P. Destrée, F. J. Gonzalez (eds.), Plato and Myth. Studies on the Use and Status of Platonic Myths, Leiden-Boston, pp. 127–164.
Cambiano, G., 19912, Platone e le tecniche, Roma-Bari.
Capuccino, C., 2011, “Plato’s Ion and the Ethics of Praise”, in: P. Destrée, F.-G. Herrmann (eds.), Plato and the Poets, Leiden-Boston, pp. 63–92.
Casanova, A., 2013, “La mimesis platonica e la fondazione della kallipolis: gioco e serietà, coerenza e contraddizione”, in: N. Notomi, L. Brisson (eds.), Dialogues on Plato’s Politeia (Republic). Selected Papers from the Ninth Symposium Platonicum, Sankt Augustin, pp. 330–335.
Cleary, J. J., 2007 (2013), “Cultivating Intellectual Virtue in Plato’s Philosopher Rulers”, in: F. L. Lisi (ed.), The Ascent to the Good, Sankt Augustin, pp. 79-100, ora in: J. Dillon, B. O’Byrne, F. O’Rourke (eds.), Studies on Plato, Aristotle and Proclus. Collected Essays on Ancient Philosophy of J. J. Cleary, Leiden-Boston, pp. 73–97.
Corradi, M., 2012, Protagora tra filologia e filosofia. Uno studio sulle testimonianze di Aristotele, Pisa.
Corradi, M., 2013, “Dal Protagora alla Repubblica: Platone e la riflessione di Protagora su letteratura e paideia“, in: N. Notomi, L. Brisson (eds.), Dialogues on Plato’s Politeia (Republic). Selected Papers from the Ninth Symposium Platonicum, Sankt Augustin, pp. 82–86.
Corradi, M., 2013a, “Τὸν ἥττω λόγον κρείττω ποιεῖν. Aristotle, Plato, and the ἐπάγγελμα of Protagoras”, in: M. Van Raalte, J. van Ophuijsen, P. Stork (eds.), Protagoras of Abdera. The Man, His Measure, Leiden-New York, pp. 69–86.
Corrigan, K., Glazov-Corrigan, E., 2004, Plato’s Dialectic at Play. Argument, Structure, and Myth in the Symposium, University Park.
Curtius, E. R., 19542 (1992), Europäische Literatur und lateinisches Mittelalter, Bern, trad. it. Firenze.
Dalfen, J., 2004, Platon. Gorgias. Übersetzung und Kommentar, Göttingen.
Delcomminette, S., 2006, Le Philèbe de Platon. Introduction à l’agathologie platonicienne, Leiden-Boston.
Demont, P., 2011, “La prónoia divine chez Hérodote (III, 108) et Protagoras (Platon, Protagoras)”, Méthexis 24, pp. 67–85.
Denyer, N., 2008, Plato. Protagoras, Cambridge-New York.
Desclos, M.-L., 1992, “Autour du Protagoras: Socrate médecin et la figure de Prométhée”, Quaderni di Storia 36, pp. 105–140.
De Sanctis, D., 2012, “Ai tempi di Crono: il duplice volto dell’umanità primitiva in Omero e in Esiodo”, in: F. Calabi, S. Gastaldi (eds.), Immagini delle origini. La nascita della civiltà e della cultura nel pensiero greco e romano, Sankt Augustin, pp. 17–39
Dörrie, H., Baltes, M., 1990, Der Platonismus in der Antike. Grundlagen – System – Entwicklung, II, Der hellenistische
Rahmen des kaiserzeitlichen Platonismus, Stuttgart-Bad Cannstatt.
Erler, M., 2007, Grundriss der Geschichte der Philosophie. Die Philosophie der Antike, II 2, Platon, Basel.
Ferrari, F., 2011, Platone. Teeteto, Milano.
Fortenbaugh, W. W., 2007, “Biography and the Aristotelian Peripatos”, in: M. Erler, S. Schorn (eds.), Die griechische Biographie in hellenistischer Zeit. Akten des internationalen Kongresses vom 26.-29. Juli 2006 in Würzburg, Berlin-New York, pp. 45–78.
Friedländer, P., 1964-19753 (2004), Platon, I-III, Berlin-New York, trad. it. Milano.
Gagarin, M., 1969, “The Purpose of Plato’s Protagoras”, Transactions and Proceedings of American Philological Association 100, pp. 133-164.
Gaiser, K., 1984, Platone come scrittore filosofico. Saggi sull’ermeneutica dei dialoghi di Platone, Napoli.
Halliwell, S., 2011, “Antidotes and Incantation: Is There a Cure for Poetry in Plato’s Republic?”, in: P. Destrée, F.-G. Herrmann (eds.), Plato and the Poets, Leiden-Boston, pp. 241–266.
Heindorf, L. F., 1810, Platonis dialogi tres. Phaedo, Sophistes, Protagoras, Berolini.
Helmig, C., Steel, C., 2012, “Proclus”, in: E. N. Zalta (ed.), The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy (Summer 2012 Edition), URL = <http://plato.stanford.edu/archives/sum2012/entries/proclus/>.
Horn, C., 2012, “Why Two Epochs of Human History? On the Myth of the Statesman”, in: C. Collobert, P. Destrée, F. J. Gonzalez (eds.), Plato and Myth. Studies on the Use and Status of Platonic Myths, Leiden-Boston, pp. 393–417.
Hourcade, A., 2009, Atomisme et sophistique. La tradition abdéritaine, Bruxelles.
Koning, H. H., 2010, Hesiod: The Other Poet. Ancient Reception of a Cultural Icon, Leiden-Boston.
Manuwald, B., 1996, “Platon oder Protagoras? Zur großen Rede des Protagoras (Plat. Prot. 320c8-328d2)”, in: C. Mueller-Goldingen, K. Sier (eds.), Ληναϊκά. Festschrift für C. W. Müller zum 65. Geburtstag am 28. Januar 1996, Stuttgart-Leipzig, pp. 103–131.
Manuwald, B., 1999, Platon. Protagoras. Übersetzung und Kommentar, Göttingen.
Manuwald, B., 2003, “Der mythos im Protagoras und die Platonische Mythopoiie”, in: A. Havlíček, F. Karfík (eds.), Plato’s Protagoras. Proceedings of the Third Symposium Platonicum Pragense, Prague, pp. 39–53.
Manuwald, B., 2013, “Protagoras’ Myth in Plato’ Protagoras: Fiction or Testimony?”, in: M. Van Raalte, J. van Ophuijsen, P. Stork (eds.), Protagoras of Abdera. The Man, His Measure, Leiden-New York, pp. 163–177.
Marino, S., 2010, “Il dialogo e la cura dell’anima: un tentativo di lettura del Protagora attraverso il paradigma medico”, in: R. Baldini (ed.), Le maschere di Aristocle. Riflessioni sulla filosofia di Platone, Villasanta, pp. 67–114.
Montanari, F., 2012, “The Peripatos on Literature. Interpretation, Use and Abuse”, in: A. Martano, E. Matelli, D. Mirhady (eds.), Praxiphanes of Mytilene and Chamaeleon of Heraclea. Texts, Translation and Discussion, New Brunswick-London, pp. 339–358.
Morgan, K. A., 2000, Myth and Philosophy from the Presocratics to Plato, Cambridge-New York.
Nestle, W., 19788, in: W. Nestle, H. Hofmann, Platon. Protagoras, Stuttgart.
Norden, E., 19232 (2002), Agnostos theos. Untersuchungen zur formengeschichte religiöser Rede, Leipzig-Berlin, trad. it. Brescia.
Notomi, N., 2011, “Image-Making in Republic X and the Sophist. Plato’s Criticism of the Poet and the Sophist,” in: P. Destrée, F.-G. Herrmann (eds.), Plato and the Poets, Leiden-Boston, pp. 299–326.
Nünlist, R., 1998, Poetologische Bildersprache in der frühgriechischen Dichtung, Stuttgart-Leipzig.
Palumbo, L., 2004, “Socrate, Ippocrate e il vestibolo dell’anima (un’interpretazione di Prot. 314c)”, in: G. Casertano (ed.), Il Protagora di Platone: struttura e problematiche, Napoli, pp. 86–103.
Pelosi, F., 2010, Plato on Music, Soul and Body, Cambridge-New York.
Rademaker, A., 2013, “The Most Correct Account: Protagoras on Language”, in: M. Van Raalte, J. van
Ophuijsen, P. Stork (eds.), Protagoras of Abdera. The Man, His Measure, Leiden-New York, pp. 87–111.
Reeve, C. D. C., 2008, “Glaucon’s Challenge and Thrasymacheanism”, Oxford Studies in Ancient Philosophy 34, pp. 69–103.
Regali, M., 2012, Il poeta e il demiurgo. Teoria e prassi della produzione letteraria nel Timeo e nel Crizia di Platone, Academia.
Richardson Lear, G., 2011, “Mimesis and Psychological Change in Republic III”, in: P. Destrée, F.-G. Herrmann (eds.), Plato and the Poets, Leiden-Boston, pp. 195–216.
Rowe, C., 2013, “On Justice and the Other Virtues in the Republic: Whose Justice, Whose Virtues?”, in: N. Notomi, L. Brisson (eds.), Dialogues on Plato’s Politeia (Republic). Selected Papers from the Ninth Symposium Platonicum, Sankt Augustin, pp. 49–59.
Saunders, T. J., 1991, Plato’s Penal Code. Tradition, Controversy, and Reform in Greek Penology, Oxford.
Schlick, A. J., 2012, “Der historische Protagoras in Platons gleichnamigem Dialog”, Museum Helveticum 69, pp. 29–44.
Schofield, M., 2010, “Music All Pow’rful“, in: M. L. McPherran (ed.), Plato’s Republic. A Critical Guide, Cambridge-New York, pp. 229–248.
Schöpsdau, K., 2011, Platon. Nomoi (Gesetze). Übersetzung und Kommentar, III, Buch VIII-XII, Göttingen.
Sedley, D., 2009, “Myth, Punishment and Politics in the Gorgias”, in: C. Partenie (ed.), Plato’s Myths, Cambridge-New York, pp. 51–76.
Serrano Cantarín, R., Díaz De Cerio Díez, M., 2005, Platón. Protágoras. Edición crítica, traducción, introducción y notas, Madrid.
Solana Dueso, J., 2011, “Protágoras y los poetas”, Convivium 24, pp. 5–23.
Stalley, R. F., 1995, “Punishment in Plato’s Protagoras”, Phronesis 40, pp. 1–19.
Tarrant, H., 2000, “Where Plato Speaks: Reflections on an Ancient Debate”, in: G. A. Press (ed.), Who Speaks for Plato? Studies in Platonic Anonymity, Lanham-Boulder-New York-Oxford, pp. 67–80.
Tulli, M., 1994, “La storia impossibile nel Politico di Platone”, Elenchos 15, pp. 5–23.
Tulli, M., 2013, “La μίμησις nel III libro della Repubblica: il rapporto di Platone con la tradizione”, in: N. Notomi, L. Brisson (eds.), Dialogues on Plato’s Politeia (Republic). Selected Papers from the Ninth Symposium Platonicum, Sankt Augustin, pp. 314–318.
Van Riel, G., 2012, “Religion and Morality. Elements of Plato’s Anthropology in the Myth of Prometheus (Protagoras, 320D–322D)”, in: C. Collobert, P. Destrée, F. J. Gonzalez (eds.), Plato and Myth. Studies on the Use and Status of Platonic Myths, Leiden-Boston, pp. 127–164.
Vegetti, M., 1998, “Glaucone”, in: M. Vegetti (ed.), Platone. La Repubblica, II, Libri II e III, Napoli, pp. 151–172.
Vegetti, M., 2004, Protagora, autore della Repubblica? (ovvero, il “mito” del Protagora nel suo contesto), in: G. Casertano (ed.), Il Protagora di Platone: struttura e problematiche, Napoli, pp. 145–158.
Vlastos, G., 1956 (1976), “Protagoras”, in: Plato. Protagoras. Translated by B. Jowett, Revised by M. Ostwald and Edited, with an Introduction, New York, pp. VII-XXIV, ora in: C. J. Classen (ed.), Sophistik, Darmstadt, pp. 271–289.
Yunis, H., 2011, Plato. Phaedrus, Cambridge-New York.
License
Peitho provides immediate open access to its content on the principle that making research freely available to the public supports a greater global exchange of knowledge.