Keywords
concept attainment
concept retention
knowledge production
geography
How to Cite
Abstract
Realising that human geography has been defined less by its canonical works but rather by its canonical concepts, the current status of the concept ‘rural’ puts a question mark over progress in human geography in terms of how well we have been able to adapt knowledge to reciprocate with societal change at large. As one of the oldest geographical concepts still in widespread use, ‘rural’ stands in stark contrast to the immense changes encountered by the society during the last century, let alone decades. And while this problem has been approached both empirically and philosophically, not enough stress has been put on the cognitive and sociological processes that have governed the attainment and retention of ‘rural’ in science, and beyond. In this vein, the aim of this paper is to provide a structured argument for facilitating a view of ‘rural’ less as a geographical space and more as a concept purportedly thought to define such space by way of inculcation.
References
Abram S., 2003. The rural gaze. In: Cloke P. (ed.), Country Visions. Pearson, Harlow: 31–48.
Anderson C.A., 2007. Belief perseverance. In: Baumeister R.F., Vohs K.D. (eds), Encyclopedia of social psychology. Sage, Thousand Oaks: 109–110.
Arsovski S., Kwiatkowski M., Lewandowska A., Jordanova Peshevska D., Sofeska E., Dymitrow M., 2018. Can urban environmental problems be overcome? The case of Skopje – world’s most polluted city. Bulletin of Geography. Socio-Economic Series 40: 17–39.
Atkinson R., 2017. Policies for small and medium-sized towns: European, national and local approaches. Tijdschrift voor economische en sociale geografie 108(4): 472–487.
Bealer R.C., Willits F.K., Kuvlesky W.P., 1965. The meaning of rurality in American society: Some implications of alternative definitions. Rural Sociology 30(3): 255–266.
Becker K.L., 2005. Individual and organisational unlearning: Directions for future research. International Journal of Organisational Behaviour 9(7): 659–670.
Bell D., Jayne M., 2009. Small cities? Towards a research agenda. International Journal of Urban and Regional Studies 33(3): 683–699.
Bennett B., Rolheiser C., 2001. Beyond Monet: The artful science of instructional integration. Bookation, Toronto.
Boisvert C.M., Faust D., 2002. Iatrogenic symptoms in psychotherapy: A theoretical exploration of the potential impact of labels, language, and belief systems. American Journal of Psychotherapy 56(2): 244–259.
Brauer R., Dymitrow M., 2014. Quality of life in rural areas: A topic for the Rural Development Policy? Bulletin of Geography. Socio-economic Series 25: 25–54.
Brauer R., Dymitrow M., 2017. Human Geography and the hinterland: The case of Torsten Hägerstrand’s belated recognition. Moravian Geographical Reports 25(2): 74–84.
Brauer R., Dymitrow M., Tribe J., 2019. The impact of tourism research, Annals of Tourism Research 77: 64–78.
Brauer R., Walsh J., Dymitrow M., Worsdell F., Tribe J., forthcoming. What is the purpose of a university… again? (in review).
Brenner N., 2015. The urban age in question: Towards a new epistemology of the urban (lecture). Melbourne School of Design, Melbourne (17 March 2015).
Bruner J., Goodnow J., Austin G., 1999. The process of concept attainment. In: Margolis E, Laurence S. (eds), Concepts: Core readings. MIT Press, Cambridge.
Buttimer A., 1976. Grasping the dynamism of lifeworld. Annals of the Association of American Geographers 66(2): 277–292.
Cagliero R., Filippa F., Pierangeli F., 2010. RDP and quality of life in rural areas: Evaluation of the possible effects in Piedmont (presentation). At: The 118th Seminar of the EAAE (European Association of Agricultural Economists) – “Rural development: Governance, policy design and delivery”. University of Ljubljana, Ljubljana (August 25–27, 2010).
Clark R.E., 2009. Resistance to change: Unconscious knowledge and the challenge of un-learning. In: Berliner D.C, Kupermintz H. (eds), Changing institutions, environments and people. Routledge, New York: 75–94.
Cloke P., 2006. Conceptualizing rurality. In: Cloke P., Marsden T., Mooney P.H. (eds), Handbook of rural studies. Sage, London: 18–28.
Cloke P., Johnston R., 2005a. Deconstructing human geography’s binaries. In: Cloke P., Johnston R. (eds), Spaces of geographical thought: Deconstructing human geography’s binaries. Sage, London: 1–20.
Cloke P., Johnston R. (eds), 2005b. Deconstructing human geography’s binaries. Sage, London.
Collins H.M., 2014. Rejecting knowledge claims inside and outside science. Social Studies of Science 44(5): 722–735.
Collins H.M., Evans R., 2008. Rethinking expertise. University of Chicago Press, Chicago.
Copp J.H., 1972. Rural sociology and rural development. Rural Sociology 37(4): 515–533.
Cosmides L., 1985. Deduction or Darwinian algorithms? An explanation of the “elusive” content effect on the Wason selection task. Harvard University, Cambridge, MA.
Couclelis H., 1992. Location, place, region, and space. In: Abler R.F., Marcus M.G., Olson J.M. (eds), Geography’s inner worlds. Rutgers University Press, New Brunswick: 215–233.
Dahlberg A., 2015. Categories are all around us: Towards more porous, flexible, and negotiable boundaries in conservation-production landscapes. Norsk Geografisk Tidsskrift–Norwegian Journal of Geography 69(4): 207–218.
Deleuze G., [1968] 1994. Difference and repetition (translated by Patton P.). Columbia University Press, New York.
Dewsbury J.-D., 2000. Performativity and the event: Enacting a philosophy of difference. Environment and Planning D: Society and Space 18(4): 473–496.
Dijkstra L., Garcilazo E., McCann P., 2013. The economic performance of cities and cityregions: Myths and realities. European Planning Studies 21(3): 334–354.
Dymitrow M., 2013. Degraded towns in Poland as cultural heritage. International Journal of Heritage Studies 19(7): 613–631.
Dymitrow M., 2014. The effigy of urbanity or a rural parody? A visual approach to small-town public space. Journal of Cultural Geography 31(1): 1–31.
Dymitrow M., 2017a. Rural/urban redux. Conceptual problems and material effects. University of Gothenburg, Gothenburg.
Dymitrow M., 2017b. Degradation, restitution and the elusive culture of rural-urban thinking. Fennia–International Journal of Geography 195(1): 36–60.
Dymitrow M., 2018. Rural/urban: Laying bare the controversy. Geographia Polonica 91(4), 375–397.
Dymitrow M., Biegańska J., Grzelak-Kostulska E., 2018. Deprivation and the rural-urban trap. Tijdschrift voor economische en sociale geografie 109(1): 87–108.
Dymitrow M., Brauer R., 2016. Land or people? On the iatrogenesis of conflation. Acta Geobalcanica 2(2): 63–75.
Dymitrow M., Brauer R., 2017. Performing rurality. But who? Bulletin of Geography. Socio-economic Series 38: 27–45.
Dymitrow M., Brauer R., 2018. Meaningful yet useless: Factors behind the retention of questionable concepts in human geography. Geografiska Annaler: Series B, Human Geography 100(3): 195–219.
Dymitrow M., Halfacree K., 2018. Sustainability–differently. Bulletin of Geography. Socio-economic Series 40: 7–16.
Dymitrow M., Stenseke M., 2016. Rural-urban blurring and the subjectivity within. Rural Landscapes: Society, Environment, History 3(1): 1–13.
ECoA (European Court of Auditors), 2011. Is agri-environment support well designed and managed? Publications Office of the European Union, Luxembourg.
Essebo M., 2013. Lock-in as make-believe – Exploring the role of myth in the lock-in of high mobility systems. University of Gothenburg, Gothenburg.
European Commission, 2008. Rural Development Policy 2007– 2013. Directorate General for Agriculture, Brussels.
European Commission, 2011. Cities of tomorrow – Challenges, visions, ways forward. Directorate General for Regional Policy, Brussels.
Falk W.W., Pinhey T.K., 1978. Making sense of the concept rural and doing rural sociology: An interpretive perspective. Rural Sociology 43(4): 547–558.
Fein S., von Hippel W., 2003. Stereotypes. In: Nadel L. (ed.), Encyclopedia of cognitive science. Nature Publishing Group, London.
Feist G.J., Gorman M.E. (eds), 2013. Handbook of the psychology of science. Springer, New York.
Feltynowski M., Senetra A., Biegańska J., Grzelak-Kostulska E., Dymitrow M., Środa-Murawska S., 2015. Some problems of local development: The example of former State Agricultural Farms in Poland. Research for Rural Development 2: 237–243.
Foucault M. [1960], 1988. Madness and civilization: A history of insanity in the age of reason. Vintage, New York.
Galjart B., 1973. The future of rural sociology. Sociologia Ruralis 13(3–4): 254–263.
Galpin C.J., 1918. Rural life. Century, New York.
Galpin C.J., Campbell W.J, Vogt P.L., 1918. Rural sociology: Standardization of research. The American Journal of Sociology 24(3): 303–310.
Gibson-Graham J.K., Roelvink G., 2010. An economic ethics for the Anthropocene. In: Castree N., Chatterton P.A., Heynen N., Larner W, Wright M.W. (eds), The point is to change it: Geographies of hope and survival in an age of crisis. Wiley-Blackwell, Oxford: 320–346.
Gilbert J., 1982. Rural theory: The grounding of rural sociology. Rural Sociology 47(4): 609–633.
Gillette J.M., 1917. The scope and methods of instruction in rural sociology. Publications of the American Sociological Society 11: 163–180.
Halfacree K.H., 1993. Locality and social representation: Space, discourse and alternative definitions of the rural. Journal of Rural Studies 9(1): 23–37.
Halfacree K., 2006. Rural space: Constructing a three-fold architecture. In: Cloke P., Marsden T., Mooney P.H. (eds), Handbook of rural studies. Sage, London: 44–62.
Halfacree K., 2009a. Urban-rural continuum. In: Kitchin R., Thrift N. (eds), International encyclopedia of human geography. Elsevier, London: 119–124.
Halfacree K., 2009b. Rurality and post-rurality. In: Kitchin R., Thrift N. (eds), International encyclopedia of human geography. Elsevier, London: 449–456.
Hamdouch A., Demazière C., Banovac K., 2017. The socio-economic profiles of small and medium-sized towns: Insights from European case studies. Tijdschrift voor economische en sociale geografie 108(4): 456–471.
Haraway D., 1991. Simians, cyborgs, and women: The reinvention of nature. Free Association Books, London.
Hassard J., 1999. Postmodernism, philosophy and management: Concepts and controversies. International Journal of Management Reviews 1(2): 171–195.
Haysom G., Olsson E.G.A., Dymitrow M., Opiyo P., Taylor Buck N., Oloko M., Spring C., Fermskog K., Ingelhag K., Kotze S., Gaya Agong S., 2019. Food systems sustainability: For whom and by whom? – An examination of different viewpoints on food system change. Sustainability 11(12): 3337.
Hedberg B., 1981. How organizations learn and unlearn. In: Nystrom P., Starbuck W.H. (eds), Handbook of organizational design (Vol. 1). Cambridge University Press, London.
Hodgkinson G.P., 1997. Cognitive inertia in a turbulent market: The case of UK residential estate agents. Journal of Management Studies 34(6): 921–945.
Hoggart K., 1990. Let’s do away with rural. Journal of Rural Studies 6(3): 245–257.
Hume D., [1748] 1975. Enquiries concerning human understanding and concerning the principles of morals. Oxford University Press, Oxford.
Jitsumori M., 2012. Artificial categories and prototype effects in animals. In: Wasserman E.A, Zentall T.R. (eds), The Oxford handbook of comparative cognition (2nd edition). Oxford University Press, Oxford: 513–532.
Johnston R., Sidaway J.D., 2015. Have the human geographical can(n)ons fallen silent; or were they never primed? Journal of Historical Geography 49: 49–60.
Jones O., 1995. Lay discourses of the rural: Developments and implications for rural studies. Journal of Rural Studies 11(1): 35–49.
Kahneman D., Klein G., 2009. Conditions for intuitive expertise: A failure to disagree. American Psychologist 64(6): 515–526.
Kavouras M., Kokla M., 2007. Theories of geographic concepts: Ontological approaches to semantic integration. CRC Press, Boca Raton.
Kegan R., Lahey L.L., 2009. Immunity to change: How to overcome it and unlock the potential in yourself and your organization. Harvard Business Press, Boston.
Kobylarek A., 2016. Seven cardinal sins of science. Journal of Education Culture and Society 2: 5–8.
Koch A., 2005. Autopoietic spatial systems: The significance of actor network theory and system theory for the development of a system theoretical approach of space. Social Geography 1(1): 5–14.
Krzysztofik R., Dymitrow M., Biegańska J., Senetra A., Gavriilidou E., Nadolu B., Kantor-Pietraga I., Grzelak-Kostulska E., Oureilidou E., Luches D., Spórna T., Teodorescu D., Wasilewicz-Pszczółkowska M., Holmertz G., Szczepańska A., Brauer R., 2017a. Landscapes with different logics: A physicalist approach to semantic conflicts in spatial planning. Quaestiones Geographicae 36(4): 29–45.
Krzysztofik R., Dymitrow M., Grzelak-Kostulska E., Biegańska J., 2017b. Poverty and social exclusion: An alternative spatial explanation. Bulletin of Geography. Socio-Economic Series 35: 45–64.
Kuhn T.S., [1962] 1970. The structure of scientific revolutions. University of Chicago Press, Chicago.
Lakatos I., Musgrave A., 1970. Criticism and the growth of scientific knowledge. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
Lamont M., 2009. How professors think: Inside the curious world of academic judgment. Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA.
Latour B., 1987. Science in action: How to follow scientists and engineers through society. Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA.
Locke J., [1690] 1975. An essay concerning human understanding. Oxford University Press, New York.
Margolis E., Laurence S. (eds), 1999. Concepts: Core readings. MIT Press, Cambridge.
Markusen A., 1999. Fuzzy concepts, scanty evidence and policy distance: The case for rigour and policy relevance in critical regional studies. Regional Studies 33(9): 869–886.
Maturana H.R., Varela F.J., [1972] 1980. Autopoiesis and cognition: The realization of the living. D. Reidel Publishing Company, Dordrecht.
Meadows D.H., 2008. Thinking in systems: A primer. Chelsea Green Publishing, White River Junction.
Newby H., 1986. Locality and rurality: The restructuring of rural social relations. In: Regional Studies 20(3): 209–215.
O’Brien K., 2013. Global environmental change III: Closing the gap between knowledge and action. Progress in Human Geography 37(4): 587–596.
Pahl R., 1966. The rural-urban continuum. Sociologia Ruralis 6(3): 299–329.
Peacocke C., 1992. A study of concepts. MIT Press, Cambridge.
Perkins D.N., 2013. Knowledge as design vs. knowledge as information. Routledge, Abingdon and New York.
Peterson J., 2015. Existentialism: Intro to biology and psychometrics (lecture). University of Toronto, Toronto (4 March 2015).
Pinker S., 2003. The blank slate: The modern denial of human nature. Penguin, London.
Pinker S., 2014. Concepts and reasoning (lecture). New College of the Humanities, London (3 October 2004).
Pinker S., 2015. Words and rules: The ingredients of language. Basic Books, New York.
Postman L., Underwood B.J., 1973. Critical issues in interference theory. Memory & Cognition 1(1): 19–40.
Pratt M.G., Barnett C.K., 1997. Emotions and unlearning in Amway recruiting techniques: Promoting change through safe ambivalence. Management Learning 28(1): 65–88.
Rey G., 1983. Concepts and stereotypes. Cognition 15(1): 237–262.
Rosch E.H., 1973. Natural categories. Cognitive Psychology 4(3): 328–350.
Schuh B., Beiglböck S., Novak S., Panwinkler T., Tordy J., Fischer M., Zondag M.-J., Dwyer J., Bański J., Saraceno E., 2012. Synthesis of mid-term evaluations of rural development programmes 2007–2013: Final report. European Commission, Directorate General for Agriculture and Rural Development, Vienna.
Seidman S., 2016. Contested knowledge: Social theory today. John Wiley & Sons, New York.
Servillo L., Atkinson R., Hamdouch A., 2017. Small and medium-sized towns in Europe: Conceptual, methodological and policy issues. Tijdschrift voor economische en sociale geografie 108(4): 365–379.
Shapiro B., 2015. The leftist thought police (lecture). Wabash College, Crawfordsville (25 March 2015).
Sher J.P., 1977. Pluralism and the countryside: A brief profile of rural America. In: Sher J.P. (ed.), Education in rural America. Westview Press, Boulder: 1–8.
Smart B., 2016. Concepts and causes in the philosophy of disease. Palgrave Macmillan, Basingstoke.
Starbuck W.H., 1996. Unlearning ineffective or obsolete technologies. International Journal of Technology Management 11(7–8): 725–737.
Stenbacka S., 2011. Othering the rural: About the construction of rural masculinities and the unspoken urban hegemonic ideal in Swedish media. Journal of Rural Studies 27(3): 235–244.
Stewart Jr C.T., 1958. The urban-rural dichotomy: Concepts and uses. American Journal of Sociology 64(2): 152–158.
Thomas N., 2011. Towards a new definition of unlearning: Rethinking individual level unlearning and its implications for practice change. Case Western Reserve University, Cleveland.
United Nations, 2014. World’s population increasingly urban with more than half living in urban areas. United Nations, New York.
Vaishar A., Zapletalová J., Nováková E., 2016. Between urban and rural: Sustainability of small towns in the Czech Republic. European Countryside 8(4): 351–372.
West L.H.T., 1985. Cognitive structure and conceptual change. Academic Press, Orlando.
Winthrop-Young G., 2014. The Kultur of cultural techniques: Conceptual inertia and the parasitic materialities of ontologization. Cultural Politics 10(3): 376–388.
Wittgenstein L., [1953] 2010. Philosophical investigations (3rd edition; translated by Anscombe, G.E.M.). Wiley-Blackwell, Oxford.
Woods C., 2006. Rural urban dichotomy disguises the problems of small towns. UN–Habitat, Nairobi.
Woods M., 2010. Performing rurality and practising rural geography. Progress in Human Geography 34(6): 835–846.
Woods M., 2011. Rural. Routledge, New York.
Young D., Borland R., Coghill K., 2010. An actor-network theory analysis of policy innovation for smoke-free places: Understanding change in complex systems. American Journal of Public Health 100(7): 1208–1217.
Žižek S., 1991. For they know not what they do: Enjoyment as a political factor. Vintage, New York.