Federal Revenue Sharing, Marginalisation and Sub-National Inter-Regional Inequality in Human Capital Development in South-Eastern and Southern Nigeria
PDF

Keywords

inequality
sub-national
region
marginalisation
competitiveness
human capital
development
states

How to Cite

Ingwe, R., Ukwayi, J. K., & Utam, E. U. (2013). Federal Revenue Sharing, Marginalisation and Sub-National Inter-Regional Inequality in Human Capital Development in South-Eastern and Southern Nigeria. Quaestiones Geographicae, 32(2), 51–68. https://doi.org/10.2478/quageo-2013-0013

Abstract

Regional development planning/management responds to needs for preventing inequality among regions within nations characterised by multi-culturality and variation among regions, through the planning/management of appropriate programmes and policies. This paper examines inequality in the development of two of Nigeria’s states in the geographical South-East and the political South-South. Among other issues, historical conflicts among various ethno-cultural groups constituting Nigeria and culminating in violence (e.g. the 1967-1970 civil war fought against the programme of Ibo (a socio-cultural group) seceding from Nigeria’s federation to found Biafra) are reviewed. Despite Nigeria’s tragic civil war, inequality persists. We examine inequality resulting from systematic implementation of policies/programmes of Nigeria’s federal government institutions that marginalise Cross River State. Using the methods of comparative analysis and a descriptive case study, we show the consequences of marginalisation policies implemented by the federal government alone or in collaboration with (i.e. in support of) Akwa Ibom State for the development of human capital in Cross River State. The specific acts of marginalisation referred to here include: the ceding of the Bakassi Peninsula - a part of Cross River State - to the Republic of Cameroon in 2005, and more recently (2009) another ceding of 76 oil wells, hitherto the property of Cross River State, to Akwa Ibom State. We argue that, strengthened by marginalising/polarising policies (higher revenue allocation based on derivation principle of oil production), Akwa Ibom’s ongoing implementation of free education policy promises to facilitate its achievement of millennium development goals in basic education by 2015, beyond which it might reach disproportionately higher levels of tertiary educational attainment by 2024 and after. By contrast, the contrived dwindling of oil revenue accruing to Cross River State deprives it of funding for competitive human capital development programme(s). We recommend that Cross River State employs serious monitoring of marginalising schemes against its people considering recent traumatising experience, and plan/implement human capital development programmes aimed to improve its competitiveness under the context of intra-regional inequality.

https://doi.org/10.2478/quageo-2013-0013
PDF

References

Adekeye F., Ubani M. & Adewuyi O., 2009. Cross River: Imoke sues RMAFC, National Boundary Commission. TELL (Lagos), 4 May: 38.

Adeniyi E.O., 1980. National development planning and plan administration in Nigeria. In: Ndekwu E.C. (ed.), Proceedingsof NISER staff seminar. Nigerian Institute of Social and Economic Research (NISER), Ibadan: 279-302.

Akam F.U., 2007/08. The politics of headcounts and statistical injustice in Nigeria - Echoes of (the) 2006 Census. Speak, 1(7): 26-27.

Alapiki H.E., 2005. State creation in Nigeria: Failed approaches to national integration and local autonomy. AfricanStudies Review, 48(3): 49-65. Retrieved 25 January 2013 from http://www.jstor.org/stable/20065139.

Andrew E.H. & Ekpenyong I., 2012. Promoting culture and tourism in Nigeria through Calabar Festival and Carnival Calabar. Mediterranean Journal of Social Sciences 3(3): 287-294. DOI: 10.5901/mjss.2012.v3n3p287. Retrieved 6 February 2013 from http://www.mcser.org.

Ayida A.A., 1971. Development objectives. In: Ayida A.A. & Onitiri H.M.A. (eds), Reconstruction and development inNigeria. Proceedings of a National Conference. Oxford University Press for NISER, Ibadan: 1-30.

Bayer K., 2009. ‘Neoliberalism’ and development policy - Dogma or progress? In: Brand U. & Sekler N. (eds), Postneoliberalism- A beginning debate. Development Dialogue, 51: 89-102.

Cross River State Government, 2009. Report of the Vision 2020 Stakeholder Development Committee for Cross River State,Nigeria. Cross River State Government, Calabar.

Fafunwa A.B., 1967. A History of Nigeria higher education: Newperspectives in African education. MacMillan, London & Lagos.

Fafunwa A.B., 2004. History of education in Nigeria. NPS Educational Publishers, Ibadan.

Igwe O., 2005. Marginalisation. Politics and Globe Dictionary. Eagle Publishers, Aba: 250-251.

Ingwe R., 2012. Physical health facilities in Nigeria’s sub-national regions: geodemographic and spatial analyses of health institutions in Nigeria’s 36 states and federal capital territory. In: Szymańska D. & Biegańska J. (eds), Bulletinof Geography, 18: 39-54. DOI: 10.2478/v10089-012-0018-0. Retrieved 25 January 2013 from http://www.bulletinofgeography.umk.pl; http://www.versita.com/bgss.

Ingwe R., 2013a. Federal government intervention in Hausa-FulaniAlmajiri education and Islamic sectarian (Boko Haram)’sterrorism in northern Nigeria: Neoliberalistic hegemonisationof Nigeria’s multi-cultural nationalities. Unpublished paper on file at the Centre for Research and Action on Developing Locales, Regions and the Environment (CRADLE).

Ingwe R., 2013b. Elitist legislators’ equivocation on “transparency,credibility and accountability” of Nigeria’s Central Bank,neoliberal-capitalist contradiction and sustainable development. Unpublished paper on file at the Centre for Research and Action on Developing Locales, Regions and the Environment (CRADLE).

Ingwe R., 2013c. Governance deficits and nationalisation ofsub-national rebellions in Nigeria: The January 2012 rebellionagainst oil subsidy removal and emerging nationalisationof revolutionary forces. Unpublished paper on file at the Centre for Research and Action on Developing Locales, Regions and the Environment (CRADLE).

Ingwe R., Ikeji C.C.C. & Ojong F.E. 2010. Neoliberal globalisation, financial and economic crises and sustainable development in Africa. ICFAI University Journal of Governanceand Public Policy, 5(4): 31-62.

Ingwe R., Ikeji C.C.C. & Ugwu U., 2011. Sub-national regional development and degree-awarding tertiary educational institutions in Nigeria: Descriptive, geo-demographic and spatial analysis. Journal of Urban and Regional Analysis, 1: 77-103.

Ingwe R., Inyang B.J., Ering S.O. & Adalikwu R.A., 2009. Sustainable energy implementation in urban Nigeria. ManagementResearch and Practice, 1(1).

Ingwe R., Okoro & Ijim-Agbor, 2012. Neoliberal policies and regimes in post-independent Nigeria at the dawn of postneoliberalism (1960-2007): A research agenda. UniversalJournal of Management and Social Sciences, forthcoming.

Isangedighi A.J., Joshua M.T., Asim A.E. & Ekuri E.E., 2004. Fundamentals of research and statistics in education and socialsciences. University of Calabar Press, Calabar.

Markussen T. & Mbuvi K., 2011. When does ethnic diversity lead to violence? Evidence from the 2007 elections in Kenya. Discussion Papers, Department of Economics, University of Copenhagen, 11-19. Retrieved 25 January 2013 from http://www.econ.ku.dk/english/research/publications/wp/dp_2011/1119.pdf/.

Murunga G.R., 2011. Spontaneous or premeditated? Post-electionviolence in Kenya. Nordiska Afrikainstitutet, Uppsala, Discussion Paper, 57.

National Bureau of Statistics, 2005. Poverty profile for Nigeria. NBS, Federal Republic of Nigeria, Abuja.

National Bureau of Statistics, 2006. Annual abstract of statistics. NBS, Federal Republic of Nigeria, Abuja.

National Bureau of Statistics, 2007a. Gender and poverty monitoring. NBS, Federal Republic of Nigeria, Abuja.

National Bureau of Statistics, 2007b. The Nigerian statisticalfact sheets on economic and social development. NBS, Federal Republic of Nigeria, Abuja: 87.

National Bureau of Statistics, 2007c. Compendium of statisticalterms: Concepts, definitions and methodologies for data productionand management in Nigeria. Chapter 20: Education. NBS, Federal Republic of Nigeria, Abuja: 945-999.

National Scholar (The), 2002. Insight (Editorial). Publication of the Academic Staff Union of Universities, September 1.

Nigeria, Federal Republic of, 2007. Official Gazette, 94(24): 180-183.

Ogunniyi M.B., 1992. Understanding research in the social sciences. University Press PLC, Ibadan.

Ojo E.O. & Adebayo P.F., 2008. The politics of states’, local governments’ creation and Nigeria’s search for geo-political balancing. African Research Review, 2(3): 334-367. Retrieved 25 January 2013 from http://afrrevjo.net/journals/multidiscipline/Vol_2_num_3_art_22_Ojo%20E%20&%20Adebayo.pdf.

Osaghae E., Ikelegbe A., Olarinmoye O. & Okhonmina S., 2007. Youth militias, self determination and resource controlstruggles in the Niger-Delta region of Nigeria. Retrieved 4 February, 2013 from http://www.ascleiden.nl/Pdf/cdpnigeriaRevisedOsaghae%5B1%5D2.pdf.

Pereira A.A., 2007. Explaining the enduring comprehensive developmentalstate in Singapore: A class relations perspective. University of Singapore.

Reich R., 1991. The work of nations: Preparing ourselves for 21stcentury capitalism. Vintage, New York.

Scott J. & Marshall G., 2005. Oxford Dictionary of Sociology. Oxford University Press, Oxford.

Spence M. (ed.), 2008. The growth report: Strategies for sustainablegrowth and inclusive development. World Bank, Washington, DC.

Springer S., 2010. Neoliberalism and geography: Expansions, variegations, formations. Geography Compass, 4/8: 1025-1038.

Springer S., 2011. Articulated neoliberalism: the specificity of patronage, kleptocracy and violence in Cambodia’s neoliberalisation. Environment & Planning A, 43: 2554-2570.

Springer S., 2012a. Neoliberalism as discourse: Between Foucauldian political economy and Marxian poststructuralism. Critical Discourse Studies, 9(2): 133-147.

Springer S., 2012b. Neoliberalising violence: Of the exceptional and the exemplary in coalescing moments. AREA (Royal Geographical Society), 44(2): 136-143. DOI:101111/j1475-4762.2012.01084.x

State Planning Commission, 2005. Cross River State economicempowerment and development strategy CR-SEEDS 2005-2007. State Planning Commission, Calabar.

Ukwayi J.K., Ingwe R. & Ojong F.E., 2012. Geodemography of health care services in the budding tourism destination of rapidly urbanising Cross River State, South-East Nigeria. Romanian Review of Regional Studies, VIII(2): 67-86.

UNDP, UNEP, World Bank & WRI, 2005. World Resources2005: The wealth of the poor (Managing ecosystems to fightpoverty). World Resources Institute (WRI), Washington, DC: 254.

Village Square (The), 2009. Panel discussion on RMFAC’s cedingof Cross River State’s 76 oil wells to Akwa Ibom State in2009 and previous ceding of Bakassi Peninsula to Cameroonand related issues with Drs. Ambrose Akpanika, Okpo Ojah,and Nelson Coco-Bassey. Cross River Broadcasting Corporation (CRBC) TV, May-June.

Webster F., 2001. Re-inventing place: Birmingham as an information city? In: Kasvio A., Laitalainen V., Salonen H. & Mero P. (eds), People, cities and the new informationeconomy (Materials from an international conference in Helsinki, 14-15 December 2000). Palmenia Kustannus, Helsinki: 128-152.