A DISCOURSE ANALYSIS OF NEWS MEDIA ARTICLES ON THE POLISH ‘RULE OF LAW CRISIS’
PDF

Keywords

discourse analysis
news media articles
the Polish constitutional crisis
rule of law
sovereignty
legal theory

How to Cite

Dersley, S. (2020). A DISCOURSE ANALYSIS OF NEWS MEDIA ARTICLES ON THE POLISH ‘RULE OF LAW CRISIS’. Comparative Legilinguistics, 44, 5–43. https://doi.org/10.2478/cl-2020-0010

Abstract

The article identifies the discursive characteristics of news media texts covering Poland’s ‘constitutional crisis’. Following the conception of discourse presented in Laclau and Mouffe (1985), i.e. as an articulatory practice that conveys meaning through a structured system of positions and differences, the article highlights some features of English-language news media texts (e.g. from the Guardian, Telegraph, Economist, Financial Times, New York Times, Washington Post) that can be described as typical. The following features are identified: a lecturing tone, the use of structural oppositions, immediate rebuttals, misrepresentation, appeals to expertise, and the sovereignty taboo. These features are diagnosed as contributing to the narrow discursive range covered by news articles. To broaden the considerations, the article presents three conflicting positions from Polish legal theory that address the issues of constitutional courts, the rule of law and national sovereignty: Ryszard Piotrowki’s legal constitutionalism, Paweł Bała and Adam Wielomski’s Schmitt-inspired position, and Adam Sulikowski’s reading of the constitutional courts as an instrument of hegemonic discourse. In the conclusion it is suggested that news media discourse would benefit from demonstrating a greater awareness of other discourses, and from developing a more generous, balanced approach to presenting and addressing their claims.

https://doi.org/10.2478/cl-2020-0010
PDF

References

Agence France-Presse. 2018. Polish Supreme Court Chief Justice Turns up to Work in Defiance of Retirement Law Being Challenged by EU (July 4). https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2018/07/04/polish-supreme-court-chief-justice-turns-work-defiance-retirement/ (accessed August 11, 2020).

Almassy, Ferenc. 2017. Eastern Europeans Begin to Grow Tired of Western Colonialism (September 14). https://visegradpost.com/en/2017/09/14/eastern-europeans-begin-to-grow-tired-of-western-colonialism/ (accessed August 13, 2020).

Applebaum, Anne. 2018. A Warning From Europe: The Worst Is Yet to Come (October). The Atlantic. https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2018/10/poland-polarization/568324/ (accessed August 7, 2020).

Bała, Paweł, and Adam Wielomski. 2015. Prawnicy o Sporze Wokół TK: Kto Jest Obrońcą Konstytucji? (December 12). Rzeczpospolita. https://www.rp.pl/Sedziowie-i-sady/312129996-Prawnicy-o-sporze-wokol-TK-Kto-jest-obronca-konstytucji.html?cid (accessed September 8, 2020).

Bartkiewicz, Artur. 2019. Sąd Najwyższy: Decyzja o Zawieszeniu Parlamentu – Nielegalna (September 24). https://www.rp.pl/Brexit/190919400-Sad-Najwyzszy-Decyzja-o-zawieszeniu-parlamentu---nielegalna.html?cid (accessed August 12, 2020).

BBC. 2018. Poland Reverses Law on Removing Judges Following EU Court Ruling (November 21). https://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-46296859 (accessed August 17, 2020).

BBC. 2019. Retirement Age: Poland Broke EU Law with Ruling on Judges (November 5). https://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-50302102 (accessed August 17, 2020).

Berendt, Joanna. 2020. E.U. Court Rules Poland Must Suspend Disciplinary Panel for Judges (April 8). New York Times. https://www.nytimes.com/2020/04/08/world/europe/poland-judges-eu-court.html (accessed September 6, 2020).

Bunikowski, Dawid. 2018. The Constitutional Crisis in Poland, Schmittian Questions and Kaczyński’s Political and Legal Philosophy. Journal of Contemporary European Studies 26 (3): 285-307, DOI: 10.1080/14782804.2018.1498771.

Chapman, Annabelle. 2020. Poland’s Leadership Doesn’t Need ‘Polexit’ – it Can Undermine the EU from Within (March 10). The Guardian https://www.theguardian.com/world/commentisfree/2020/mar/10/poland-polexit-eu-rightwing-law-justice-party-judiciary (accessed August 6, 2020).

Costa, Petro. 2007. The Rule of Law: A Historical Introduction. In The Rule of Law History, Theory and Criticism, by Pietro Costa and Danilo Zolo, 73-152. Dordrecht: Springer.

Csasky, Zselyke. 2018. It’s Time to Play Hardball With Poland (March 14). ttps://foreignpolicy.com/2018/03/14/its-time-to-play-hardball-with-poland/ (accessed August 16, 2020).

European Commission. 2017. Rule of Law: European Commission Acts to Defend Judicial Independence in Poland (December 20).https://ec.europa.eu/commission/presscorner/detail/en/IP_17_5367 (accessed July 27, 2020).

Fairclough, Norman. 1992. Discourse and Social Change. Cambridge: Polity Press.

Fairclough, Norman. 1995. Critical Discourse Analysis. The Critical Study of Language. London: Longman.

Financial Times. 2019. Poland Must Not Slide Further into Illiberalism (October 16). https://www.ft.com/content/32fed8bc-ef5e-11e9-bfa4-b25f11f42901 (accessed August 16, 2020).

Financial Times. 2020. In Poland, The Rule of Law is Under Ever Greater Threat (February 9). https://www.ft.com/content/d2390d6e-49a2-11ea-aeb3-955839e06441 (accessed August 16, 2020).

Foster, Peter. 2016. What Would Brexit Mean for British Sovereignty? (June 8). The Telegraph. https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2016/05/19/how-does-the-eu-impinge-on-british-sovereignty-and-if-the-uk-vot/ (accessed September 6, 2020).

Foster, Peter. 2017. Poland’s Constitutional Crisis Threatens to Pull EU Apart (July 27). The Telegraph.. https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2017/07/26/special-report-polands-constitutional-crisis-threatens-pull/ (accessed September 6, 2020).

Foucault, Michel. 1972. The Archaeology of Knowledge. Transl. A.M. Sheridan Smith. United Kingdom: Tavistock Publications Ltd.

Foucault, Michel. 1981. The Order of Discourse. In Untying the Text, ed. Robert Young, 48-77. Boston: Routledge & Kegan Paul.

Halliday, Michael A.K. 2003. The Functional Basis of Language (1973). In On Language and Linguistics, ed. Jonathan Webster, 298-322. London: Continuum.

Halliday, Michael A.K. 2014. Halliday’s Introduction to Functional Grammar, revised by Christian M.I.M. Matthiessen. Oxon: Routledge.

Iustitia. 2018. Response to the White Paper Compendium on the Reforms of the Polish Justice System (March 16). https://www.iustitia.pl/informacje/2172-response-to-the-white-paper-compendium-on-the-reforms-of-the-polish-justice-system-presented-by-the-government-of-the-republic-of-poland-to-the-european-commission (accessed August 15, 2010).

Jorgensen, Marianne, and Loiuse J. Phillips. 2002. Discourse Analysis as Theory and Method. London: Sage Publications.

Krotoszyński, Michał. 2014. Polish Lustration and the Models of Transitional Justice. Adam Mickiewicz University Law Review 3: 199-211.

Laclau, Ernesto, and Chantal Mouffe. 1985. Hegemony and Socialist Strategy. London: Verso.

Michnik, Adam. 2020. Brexit – Lekcja dla Polski (January 31). https://wyborcza.pl/7,75399,25650336,brexit-lekcja-dla-polski.html (accessed August 13, 2020).

Mowat, Laura. 2019. Brussels Fury: Poland Could be KICKED OUT of EU over Controversial Reforms (December 19). https://www.express.co.uk/news/world/1219112/eu-news-poland-supreme-court-judicial-reforms-law-and-justice (accessed August 11, 2020).

Pancevski, Bojan. 2017. Inflamed Poland scorns Brussels (August 6). The Times.

https://www.thetimes.co.uk/article/inflamed-poland-scorns-brussels-7zwnzf8l7 (accessed September 6, 2020).

Pech, Laurent, and R. Daniel Kelemen. 2020. If You Think The U.S. Is Having a Constitutional Crisis, You Should See What Is Happening in Poland (January 25). Washington Post. https://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/2020/01/25/if-you-think-us-is-having-constitutional-crisis-you-should-see-what-is-happening-poland/ (accessed September 6, 2020).

Phillips, Damien. 2019. A No-Deal Brexit Is Our Safest Option to Escape The EU Police State – Let's Go for It (February 8). Telegraph. https://www.telegraph.co.uk/politics/2019/02/08/no-deal-brexit-safest-option-escape-eu-police-state/ (accessed August 6, 2020).

Piotrowski, Ryszard. 2018. Judges and the Limits of Democratic Power in the Light of The Constiution of The Republic of Poland. Ruch Prawniczy, Ekonomiczny i Socjologiczny Rok LXXX – zeszyt 1: 215-229, https://pressto.amu.edu.pl/index.php/rpeis/article/download/12639/19348/ (accessed August 8, 2020).

Rybarczyk, Marek. 2019. Sąd Najwyższy Ratuje Honor Brytyjskiej Demokracji. Co Dalej z Brexitem? (September 24). https://www.polityka.pl/tygodnikpolityka/swiat/1925930,1,sad-najwyzszy-ratuje-honor-brytyjskiej-demokracji-co-dalej-z-brexitem.read (accessed August 12, 2020).

Santora, Marc. 2018. Polish Crisis Deepens as Judges Condemn Their Own Court (July 5). New York Times. https://www.nytimes.com/2018/07/05/world/europe/poland-court-crisis-constitutional-tribunal.html. (Accessed August 13, 2020).

Schmitt, Carl. 1985. Political Theology (transl. George Schwab). Chicago: The University of Chicago Press.

Schmitt, Carl. 1996. The Concept of the Political (transl. George Schwab). Chigaco: University of Chicago Press.

Shotter, James, and Agata Majos. 2019. Poland election: the Unfinished Counter-Revolution The Law and Justice Party Has Overseen Growth While Mobilising Voters Who Feel Left Behind (October 9).

https://www.ft.com/content/176e701c-e8ec-11e9-85f4-d00e5018f061 (accessed August 17, 2020).

Stanisław Skarżyński. 2019. Sąd Najwyższy Jednomyślnie Posłał Johnsona na Deski. ‘Zawieszenie Parlamentu Jest Bezprawiem i Jest Bezskuteczne (September 24) https://wyborcza.pl/7,75399,25229136,sad-najwyzszy-jednomyslnie-poslal-johnsona-na-deski-prorogacja.html. (accessed August 12, 2010).

Sulikowski, Adam. 2016. „Konstytucja – System – Hegemonia. „(Anty)Polityczna” Funkcja Argumentów Systemowych w Orzecznictwie Konstytucynym” Przegląd Prawa i Administracji 104: 251-263.

The Economist. 2020. Law and Justice v Law and Justice (January 25). London: The Economist Newspaper Limited.

The Guardian. 2020. The Guardian View on Poland’s Presidential Election: Call It off. (May 5). https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2020/may/05/the-guardian-view-on-polands-presidential-election-call-it-off (accessed August 7, 2020).

van Dijk, Teun A. 2009. Society and Discourse. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

van Dijk, Teun A. 2014. Discourse and Knowledge. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

White Paper on The Reform of The Polish Judiciary. March 7 2020. The Chancellery of the Prime Minister. https://www.premier.gov.pl/files/files/white_paper_en_full.pdf (accessed August 9, 2020).

When submitting a paper the author agrees to the following publishing agreement and processing personal data.

PUBLICATION AGREEMENT, COPYRIGHT LICENSE, PERSONAL DATA PROCESSING CONSENT

This is a publication agreement and copyright license (“Agreement”) regarding a written manuscript currently submitted via Pressto platform

 (“Article”) to be published in Comparative Legilinguistics International Journal for Legal Communication (“Journal”).

The parties to this Agreement are:

the Author or Authors of the submitted article (individually, or if more than one author, collectively, “Author”) and Comparative Legilinguistics International Journal for Legal Communication (“Publisher”), address al. Niepodległości 4, 61-874 Poznań, represented by its editor in chief Aleksandra Matulewska.

§1. LICENSE OF COPYRIGHT

a)     The Author and the Publisher agree that the Author grants a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License, which is incorporated herein by reference and is further specified at Creative Commons — Attribution 4.0 International — CC BY 4.0 copyright license in the Article to the general public.

b)     The Author grants to the Publisher a royalty-free, worldwide nonexclusive license to publish, reproduce, display, distribute, translate and use the Article in any form, either separately or as part of a collective work, including but not limited to a nonexclusive license to publish the Article in an issue of the Journal, copy and distribute individual reprints of the Article, authorize reproduction of the entire Article in another publication, and authorize reproduction and distribution of the Article or an abstract thereof by means of computerized retrieval systems (such as Westlaw, Lexis and SSRN). The Author retains ownership of all rights under copyright in the Article, and all rights not expressly granted in this Agreement.

c)     The Author grants to the Publisher the power to assign, sublicense or otherwise transfer any and all licenses expressly granted to the Publisher under this Agreement.

d)     Republication. The Author agrees to require that the Publisher be given credit as the original publisher in any republication of the Article authorized by the Author. If the Publisher authorizes any other party to republish the Article under the terms of paragraphs 1c and 1 of this Agreement, the Publisher shall require such party to ensure that the Author is credited as the Author.

§2. EDITING OF THE ARTICLE

a)     The Author agrees that the Publisher may edit the Article as suitable for publication in the Journal. To the extent that the Publisher’s edits amount to copyrightable works of authorship, the Publisher hereby assigns all right, title, and interest in such edits to the Author.

§3.  WARRANTIES

a)     The Author represents and warrants that to the best of the Author’s knowledge the Article does not defame any person, does not invade the privacy of any person, and does not in any other manner infringe upon the rights of any person. The Author agrees to indemnify and hold harmless the Publisher against all such claims.

b)     The Author represents and warrants that the Author has full power and authority to enter into this Agreement and to grant the licenses granted in this Agreement.

c)     The Author represents and warrants that the Article furnished to the Publisher has not been published previously. For purposes of this paragraph, making a copy of the Article accessible over the Internet, including, but not limited to, posting the Article to a database accessible over the Internet, does not constitute prior publication so long as the as such copy indicates that the Article is not in final form, such as by designating such copy to be a “draft,” a “working paper,” or “work-in-progress”. The Author agrees to hold harmless the Publisher, its licensees and distributees, from any claim, action, or proceeding alleging facts that constitute a breach of any warranty enumerated in this paragraph.

§4. TERM

a)     The agreement was concluded for an unspecified time.

§5. PAYMENT

a)     The Author agrees and acknowledges that the Author will receive no payment from the Publisher for use of the Article or the licenses granted in this Agreement.

b)     The Publisher agrees and acknowledges that the Publisher will not receive any payment from the Author for publication by the Publisher.

§6. ENTIRE AGREEMENT

a)     This Agreement supersedes any and all other agreements, either oral or in writing, between the Author and the Publisher with respect to the subject of this Agreement. This Agreement contains all of the warranties and agreements between the parties with respect to the Article, and each party acknowledges that no representations, inducements, promises, or agreements have been made by or on behalf of any party except those warranties and agreements embodied in this Agreement.

b)     In all cases not regulated by this Agreement, legal provisions of Polish Copyright Act and Polish Civil Code shall apply. 

c)     Any disputes arising from the enforcement of obligations connected with this Agreement shall be resolved by a court competent for the headquarters of the Publisher.

d)     Any amendments or additions to the Agreement must be made in writing and signed by authorised representative of both parties, otherwise being ineffective. 

e)      This Agreement is signed electronically and the submission of the article via the PRESSto platform is considered as the conclusion of the Agreement by the Author and the Publisher.

f)     Clause for consent to the processing of personal data - general

g)     The Author shall give his or her consent to the processing of their personal data in accordance with the Act of 10 May 2018 on the protection of personal data and Regulation (EU) 2016/679 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 27 April 2016 on the protection of persons physical in connection with the processing of personal data and on the free movement of such data, and repealing Directive 95/46 / EC (General Data Protection Regulation) for the purpose and in connection with making publications available on the PRESSto scientific journals platform and DeGruyter platform, guaranteeing the security of services rendered, and improving them.

I HAVE READ AND AGREE FULLY WITH THE TERMS OF THIS AGREEMENT.

The Author                             The Publisher

 

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.