Why Is Recreational Hunting a Moral Evil?

Main Article Content

Anna Szklarska

Abstract

The paper reviews the recent book edited by Dorota Probucka, entitled The Ethical Condemnation of Hunting (in Polish: Etyczne potępienie myślistwa), Universitas Press, Kraków 2020, pp. 426. Probucka is one of the most prominent Polish experts in animal studies, especially in applied ethics and the field of animal rights (e.g., Probucka 2018a, 2018b, 2017). The discussed monograph encompasses the contributions of 19 authors representing 9 universities from Poland and abroad. Their core issue of consideration was the topical problem of hunting, examined from various perspectives: ethical and legal, psychological, social and cultural, both on the theoretical level and in relation to the practice of hunting. This review focuses on the core arguments against hunting and discusses them in detail.The Ethics in Progress journal had the honour of contributing to the media patronage of Dorota Probucka’s et al. edition.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

Article Details

How to Cite
Szklarska, A. (2020). Why Is Recreational Hunting a Moral Evil?. ETHICS IN PROGRESS, 11(2), 70-79. https://doi.org/10.14746/eip.2020.2.7
Section
Core topics-related articles
Author Biography

Anna Szklarska, Pedagogical University of Cracow

Anna Szklarska, PhD and assistant professor at the Chair of Social Philosophy, Institute of Philosophy and Sociology of Pedagogical University in Cracow, Poland. Her research interests include Ethics, history of philosophy, social and political philosophy, philosophical anthropology, philosophy of culture, and bioethics. She has authored numerous articles and books, including Identity, Violence, Religion. The Dilemmas of Modern Philosophy of Man (2014, in Engl.) and Justice in Times of Crisis (2015).

References

  1. Cyrol T. 2020. „Czy myślistwo rekreacyjne jest zgodne z prawem?” [Engl. Is recreational hunting lawful?], in D. Probucka (Ed.), Etyczne potępienie myślistwa [Engl. The ethical condemnation of hunting] (pp. 31–42). Kraków: Universitas.
  2. Dąbek D. 2020. “O instrumentalnym traktowaniu etyki przez myśliwych” [Engl. On the instrumental treatment of ethics by hunters], in D. Probucka (Ed.), Etyczne potępienie myślistwa (pp. 91–105). Kraków: Universitas.
  3. Elżanowski A. 2002. „Prymitywizm motywacji do polowania” [Engl. The primitivism of being motivated for hunting], in D. Probucka (Ed.), Etyczne potępienie myślistwa (pp. 57–73). Kraków: Universitas.
  4. Helios J. & Jedlecka W. 2017. „Okrucieństwo wobec zwierząt z punktu widzenia psychologii i filozofii – zarys problemu” [Engl. Cruelty to animals from a psychological and philosophical view – an outline of the problem], Acta Universitatis Wratislaviensis 3759:31–44.
  5. Jedzok D. 2002. „Zabójstwo z miłości. Kartezjańskie dychotomie w argumentacji zwolenników myślistwa rekreacyjnego” [Engl. Murder triggered by love. Cartesian dichotomies in the arguments of the supporters of recreational hunting], in D. Probucka (Ed.), Etyczne potępienie myślistwa (75–90). Kraków: Universitas.
  6. Kołakowski L. 1990. Cywilizacja na ławie oskarżonych [Engl. Civilization in the dock]. Warsaw: Res Publica.
  7. Korpikiewicz H. 2020. „Moje hobby: zabijanie” [Engl. My hobby: Killing], in D. Probucka (Ed.), Etyczne potępienie myślistwa (pp. 43–55). Kraków: Universitas.
  8. Kruczyński Z. 2017. Farba znaczy krew [Engl. Paint means blood]. Wołowiec: Czarne Press.
  9. Matkowski T. 2009. Polowaneczko [Engl. A sweet little hunting]. Warszawa: Nowy Świat Press.
  10. Olson M. 2014. The Compassionate Hunter’s Guidebook: Hunting from the Heart. New Society Publishers.
  11. Plato 2008. Gorgias. Trans. B. Jovett. The Gutenberg Project (e-source, retrieved on December 25, 2020; https://www.gutenberg.org/files/1672/1672-h/1672-h.htm).
  12. Plato 2007-2012. Crito. Trans. C. Woods & B. Pack (e-source, retrieved on December 25, 2020; https://www.pitt.edu/~mthompso/readings/crito.pdf)
  13. Probucka D. (Ed.) 2020. Etyczne potępienie myślistwa [Engl. Ethical condemnation of hunting]. Kraków: Universitas.
  14. Probucka D. 2018a. “Ethical Condemnation of Recreational Hunting,” Zoophilologica. Polish Journal of Animal Studies 4:141–147.
  15. Probucka D. 2018b. “On the Concept of Ecological Solidarity. What Connects Animal Rights with the Rights of Human Beings?,” Humanistyka & Przyrodoznawstwo 24:39–47.
  16. Probucka D. 2017. “European Philosophy and Its Negative Impact on the Treatment of Animals,” Zoophilologica. Polish Journal of Animal Studies 3:155–162.
  17. Skubała P. 2018. „Czy polowania w dzisiejszym świecie mają rację bytu?” [Engl. Do we need hunting in today’s world?], Zoophilologica. Polish Journal of Animal Studies 4:105–119.