Keywords
meat scandal
penal policy in socialist Poland
Władysław Gomułka
How to Cite
Number of views: 99
Number of downloads: 57
Abstract
The pivotal motive behind financial crime in the real socialist states was the chronic shortage of goods and services. In the case of Poland under the Gomułka administration (1956-1970), a factor which contributed to the prevalence of practices considered economically criminal was, ironically, the liberalization of the government in the period following Władysław Gomułka’s rise to power. The procedure of issuing new licenses to private and co-operative manufacturing businesses fostered illegal practices, because the new businesses needed supplies of deficit resources. Private trade businesses struggled with similar problems. The authorities tried to prevent financial crime by concentrating on publishing new laws which allowed heavy punishment for those behind the biggest economic scandals. In this field, the penal policy was shaped by the top authorities of the communist party, and their decisions were binding for the institutions of the justice system. Such decisions of the top authorities of the Polish United Workers’ Party (PUWP) were behind the death sentence for Stanisław Wawrzecki, who was charged with fraudulence in meat trade in Warsaw. Poles’ attitude towards financial crime was not clear-cut. One the one hand, in their letters to authorities, many Poles expressed their support for severe punishment for those responsible for the biggest fraud, while others objected towards capital punishment for Wawrzecki. The information we have on the dynamics of confirmed financial crimes does not provide a clear answer whether it was actually related to the severity of the punishments.
References
Archiwum Akt Nowych – Kancelaria Sejmu PRL [Archive of New Files – PRL Sejm Office].
Archiwum Akt Nowych – Komitet Centralny Polskiej Zjednoczonej Partii Robotniczej [AAN – Central Committee of the Polish United Workers’ Party].
Archiwum Akt Nowych – Ministerstwo Sprawiedliwości [AAN – the Ministry of Justice].
Archiwum Akt Nowych –Najwyższa Izba Kontroli [AAN – Supreme Audits Office].
Archiwum Akt Nowych – Polskie Towarzystwo Ekonomiczne [AAN – Polish Economic Society].
Archiwum Akt Nowych – Prokuratura Generalna PRL [AAN – socialist Poland Prosecution General].
Archiwum Akt Nowych – Urząd Rady Ministrów [AAN – Chancellery of the Prime Minister].
Archiwum Dokumentacji Historycznej PRL – Kolekcja Stefana Jędrychowskiego [Historic documentation of Socialist Poland Archive – Stefan Jędrychowski’s collection].
Archiwum Ośrodka Dokumentacji i Zbiorów Programowych TVP S.A. – Biuletyn Biura Listów Komitetu do Spraw Radiofonii „Polskie Radio” [The Archive of the Center of TVP S.A. Documentation and Programs – Bulletin of the Correspondence Bureau of the “Polskie Radio” Radio Committee].
Archiwum Państwowe w Warszawie – Komitet Warszawski Polskiej Zjednoczonej Partii Robotniczej [National Archive in Warsaw – Warsaw Committee of the Polish United Workers’ Party].
Archiwum Akt Nowych – Supreme Audits Office, sign. 17/57, the Analysis of the documents concerning 18 financial crime cases {1957} ff 46-54
Archiwum Dokumentacji Historycznej PRL – Kolekcja Stefana Jędrychowskiego sygn. J I/53, Główne problemy sytuacji gospodarczej kraju roku 1957, k. 261 [Historic documentation of PRL Archive – Stefan Jędrychowski’s collection sign. J I/53, The main problems of the state economy. General assessment of the year 1957, f. 261].
AAN – Polish Economic Society sign. 167, The review of the current, national economic situation and the tasks of the state.
AAN – Chancellery of the Prime Minister of PRL, 4th term, sign. 659659, Explanatory memorandum to the overruling Act on financial co-responsibility of employees for shortages in trade companies, ff 29-30.
Penal Code of the Soviet Union, Trial Code of the Soviet Union, Act on the judiciary system in the Soviet Union, Warsaw 1961, p. 129-130.
AAN – Central Committee of the Polish United Worker’s Party, sign XI/281, Report of the Central Unit for fighting with fraud and corruption for the period 1.06 - 30.06 1958.
AAN – Central Committee of PUWP, sign. XI/281, the letter of the Secretariat of KC PUWP on the subject of Units for fighting with fraud and corruption, July 1958, ff 18-19.
AAN – Central Committee PUWP, sign. VII/149, Attachment 1 to the Bulletin no 115 of the Secretariat Bureau of the Central Committee of PUWP, May 16, 1963. Letter of the Organizational Department of the Central Committee and Party Central Committee to the 1st secretaries of regional committees, ff 249-251.
Resolution of the 3rd Convention on crucial political tasks for the Party, “Nowe Drogi” (ND), 1959, no 4, p. 656.
AAN – Central Committee of PUWP, sign. 237/V/453, Information of the Prosecution General on the execution of the directive of the Political Bureau of the Central Committee of PUWP of January 19 1959, ff 51-52.
AAN – PRL Prosecution General, sign. 23/37, the decision of Polish Council of State, Warsaw, March 31, 1961, f. 73.
AAN – Central Committee of PUWP, sign. 237/XIV-305, Note on the more serious fraud in meat, baking, seeding and leather industries sent by the PRL Prosecutor General, Kazimierz Kosztirko to the secretary of PUWP Central Committee, Ryszard Strzelecki, Warsaw, September 17, 1964, ff 65-66.
AAN – Central Committee of PUWP, sign. 237/XIV-305, Note on the more serious fraud in meat, baking, seeding and leather industries sent by the PRL Prosecutor General, Kazimierz Kosztirko to the secretary of PUWP Central Committee, Ryszard Strzelecki, Warsaw, September 17, 1964, ff 65-66.
AAN –PUWP Central Committee, sign. 2221 (micr. 3378), Protocol no 15 of the cases resolved by the Central Committee Secretariat, ff 444.
AAN – Ministry of Justice, sign. 1/369, Information on the execution in the years 1962-1964 requests concerning the penal policy confirmed by the Central Committee Secretariat on September 20, 1961, ff 21-22, 25-27.
AAN – Ministry of Justice, sign. 1/369, Information on the execution in the years 1962-1964 requests concerning the penal policy confirmed by the Central Committee Secretariat on September 20, 1961, f. 44; ibidem, Jurisdiction [1966], ff 151; AAN – Sejm Office, sign. 721, Act of qualifying less serious crimes as offences and transferring them to penal and administration jurisdiction [bill], ff 279-297.
AAN – The Council of Ministers, sign. 14/4, Report on the activities of the Complaints and Letters Office of PUWP Central Committee in 1961, ff 5-14, ibidem, Report on the activities of the Complaints and Letters Office of PUWP Central Committee in 1963, f. 63, ibidem Report on the activities of the Complaints and Letters Office of PUWP Central Committee in 1965, f. 138.
AAN – PUWP Central Committee, sign. 237/XXV-68, Bulletin no 4/342, Warsaw, July 24, 1964, f. 34.
The Archive of the Center of TVP S.A. Documentation and Programs, sign. 1050/30, Bulletin of the Correspondence Bureau of the “Polskie Radio” Radio Committee, no 4, February 3, 1960, ff without the page number.
AAN – PUWP Central Committee, sign. 237/VII-5217, Information no 34/A/3992, June 14 1964 r., f. 73.
AAN – PUWP Central Committee, sign. 237/VII-5217, Information no 36/A/3994, June 17 1964 r., f. 77.
AAN – PUWP Central Committee, sign. 237/VII-5217, Information no 40/A/3998, June 20 1964 r., f. 90.
AAN – PUWP Central Committee, sign.237/VII-5217, Information no 47/A/4005, July 18 1964, f. 101.
National Archive in Warsaw – Warsaw Committee of the PUWP, sign 30/VII-43, vol. 24, Information no 8/VII/451 of the Information Sector of the Organizational Department of PUWP Regional Committee on the first reactions to the information in today’s “Trybuna Ludu” newspaper regarding fraud in meat trade (developed based on conversations with district and company committees), f. 264.
National Archive in Warsaw – Warsaw Committee of the Polish United Workers’ Party, sign 30/VII-43, vol. 24, Information no 11/VII/454 on further reactions to the information in yesterday’s “Trybuna Ludu” newspaper concerning fraud in meat trade, ff 269-270.
National Archive in Warsaw – Warsaw Committee of the Polish United Workers’ Party, sign. 30/VII-43, vol. 24, Information no 9/VII/452 on further reactions to the information in today’s “Trybuna Ludu” newspaper concerning fraud in meat trade, f. 266.
AAN – PUWP Central Committee, sign. 237/VII-5219, Information no 71/2373, July 9 1964, Results of the survey concerning the 4th Party Convention. Declarations and the statement concerning the Party Convention ff 18-19.
The Archive of the Center of TVP S.A. Documentation and Programs, sign. 1050/21, Bulletin of the Correspondence Bureau of the “Polskie Radio” Radio Committee, no 49, July 5 1957.
The Archive of the Center of TVP S.A. Documentation and Programs, sign. 1050/19, Bulletin of the Correspondence Bureau of the “Polskie Radio” Radio Committee, no 78, December 14 1957.
The Archive of the Center of TVP S.A. Documentation and Programs, sign. 1050/61, Bulletin of the Correspondence Bureau of the “Polskie Radio” Radio Committee no 134, February 1965.
AAN – PRL Prosecution General, sign. 1/29, Bulletin of the Correspondence Bureau of the “Polskie Radio” Radio Committee no 134, February 1965, Subject: opinions on sentences in the meat swindle trial, ff 11-27.
Andrejew I. (1971), Zagadnienia prawa karnego państw socjalistycznych [Problems of the criminal law in the socialist states] Warsaw.
Chumiński J. (2015), Robotnicy polscy 1945-1956. „Stary” i „nowy” ośrodek przemysłowy na przykładzie Krakowa i Wrocławia [Polish workers 1945-1956. Old and new industrial centers based on the examples of Kraków and Wrocław], Wrocław.
Dudek A., Kochański A., Persak K. (2000), Centrum władzy. Protokoły posiedzeń kierownictwa PUWP. Wybór z lat 1949-1970, [The center of power. Protocols from the meetings of PUWP management. Selection from the years 1949-1970], Warsaw.
Journal of Laws.
Grabarczyk G. (2002), Przestępczość gospodarcza na tle przemian ustrojowych w Polsce [Financial crime and the political transformation in Poland], Toruń.
Grześkowiak A. (1982), Kara śmierci w polskim prawie karnym [Death penalty in the Polish legal system], Toruń.
Jarosz D., Pasztor M. (2004), Afera mięsna: fakty i konteksty [Meat swindle: facts and context], Toruń.
Kochanowski J. (2010), Tylnymi drzwiami. „Czarny rynek” w Polsce 1944-1989 [Through the back door. Black market in Poland 1944–1989], Warsaw.
Kornai J. (1985), Niedobór w gospodarce [Shortages in the economy], Warsaw.
Koralewicz J. (1987), Autorytaryzm, lęk, konformizm: analiza społeczeństwa polskiego końca lat siedemdziesiątych [Authoritarianism, fear and conformity: the analysis of the Polish society in the late 1970s], Wrocław.
Madej K. (2010), Bezradność lub represja. Władze wobec przestępczości gospodarczej w PRL (1956-1970) [Helplessness or repression. The authorities and financial crime in socialist Poland (1956-1970)], Warsaw.
Madej K. (2002), Kara śmierci za mięso, [Death Penalty for Meat], “Biuletyn Instytutu Pamięci Narodowej”, no 11.
Madej K. (2006), Prawo i wymiar sprawiedliwości PRL wobec przestępczości gospodarczej [Law and justice of socialist Poland against financial crimes], “Pamięć i Sprawiedliwość” no 2, p. 143-166.
Majchrzak I. (1965), Pracownicze przestępstwo gospodarcze i jego sprawca [Economic crimes of employees and the perpetrators], Warsaw.
Pamiętniki prawników. Wybór prac nadesłanych na konkurs pod nazwą „Pamiętniki prawników. Wspomnienia z 25 lat Polski Ludowej [Lawyers’ diaries. The selection of works sent to the „Lawyers’ diaries. Memories on the 25th anniversary of the socialist Poland” competition], Warsaw, 1969.
Podgórecki A. (1966), Prestiż prawa [The prestige of law], Warsaw.
Podgórecki A. (1971), Rygoryzm a tolerancja [Rigor and tolerance], [in:] Podgórecki A., Kurczewski J., Kwaśniewski J., Łoś M. (1971), Poglądy społeczeństwa polskiego na moralność i prawo (Wybrane problemy) [Views of the Polish society on morality and law (selected problems)], Warsaw.
Podgórecki A., Kurczewski J., Kwaśniewski J., Łoś M. (1971), Poglądy społeczeństwa polskiego na moralność i prawo (Wybrane problemy) [Views of the Polish society on morality and law (selected problems)], Warsaw.
Prestiż prawa. Problematyka, zakres i metody badań [Prestige of law. Problems, scope and research methods], OBOP, Warsaw 1966.
Wytyczne wymiaru sprawiedliwości i praktyki sądowej w sprawie niektórych zagadnień w procesach o niedobory (K.O. 145/52) [Guidelines of the justice system and court practice regarding some problems with shortage trials (K.O. 145/52), [in:] Bafia J., Hochberg L., Siewierski M. (1965), Ustawy karne PRL. Komentarz [Penal acts of socialist Poland. Commentary], Warsaw.
License
Copyright (c) 2021 Dariusz Jarosz
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.