Review process

Review process

All submissions are first reviewed by the editorial board for suitability and compliance with the profile of the journal and then subjected to double-blind peer-review by at least two external reviewers. In normal circumstances and depending on the reviewer availability the turnaround for a manuscript should not take more than 3-4 months.

Thank you for agreeing to review for Studia Anglica Posnaniensia. The editorial team highly appreciates the time and effort you have offered to improve the quality of the papers published in our journal. Please complete all sections of the review form in the system and return it to the assistant editor within 5 weeks of the receipt of the paper.

See Instructions to the reviewers

Timeliness and review report

Please submit your review by the deadline indicated in the invitation (the time allocated for a review is 5 weeks). If you are unable to meet the deadline, please inform the editorial office as soon as possible.

Please assess the manuscript in terms of its originality, scholarly significance, methodological rigour, clarity of argument, and contribution to the journal’s scope. Comments should be specific, constructive, and respectful. Where possible, distinguish between issues that must be addressed before publication and suggestions that are optional or a matter of scholarly preference.

Discipline-specific considerations

For linguistics submissions, please consider whether:

  • the data, corpus, participants, instruments, and/or analytical procedures are described sufficiently to evaluate the study;
  • the methodology is suitable for the research question and, where relevant, supports replication or transparent re-analysis;
  • quantitative or qualitative evidence is interpreted accurately and cautiously;
  • examples, glosses, transcriptions, annotations, and statistical reporting are clear and consistently formatted.

For literary, cultural, and comparative-studies submissions, please consider whether:

  • the textual, historical, cultural, and/or theoretical context is sufficiently established;
  • close reading or other interpretive analysis is sustained, precise, and supported by appropriate evidence;
  • the article moves beyond description or plot summary to develop an original critical argument;
  • primary and secondary materials are used responsibly and accurately.

Use of generative AI

Please do not upload the manuscript, any part of it, or any supplementary material to publicly available generative AI tools, such as ChatGPT, Copilot, Gemini, or similar systems. Doing so may compromise the confidentiality, intellectual property, and data security of the submission.

Please do not use generative AI to analyse, summarise, evaluate, or generate your review report. The review must represent your own scholarly judgement, and you remain responsible for its accuracy, fairness, rigour, and constructive tone.

You may use generative AI only in a limited way to improve the grammar, clarity, or style of your own review comments, provided that no confidential manuscript content is entered into the tool. If you use AI in this limited way, please disclose this to the handling editor when submitting your report.

If you are unsure whether a particular tool is appropriate, please do not use it. In particular, avoid tools whose terms of use permit user inputs to be stored, used for model training, or shared with third parties.

Confidentiality and conflicts of interest

Please treat the manuscript, supplementary materials, and the review process as confidential. Do not share the manuscript or discuss its contents with anyone other than the journal’s editors. Before accepting the invitation, please inform the editors of any actual or potential conflict of interest, including a recent professional collaboration within the last five years, institutional affiliation, supervisory relationship, or personal connection with the author(s).

Ethical considerations

Please alert the editors if you notice potential ethical problems, including plagiarism, unattributed reuse of text or ideas, fabricated or manipulated data, duplicate publication, undisclosed conflicts of interest, or inadequate acknowledgement of sources. Concerns should be raised with the editors rather than addressed directly with the author(s).