Abstract
The article aims to determine how the change in the status quo in the aftermath of the Karabakh war in 2020 influenced Russia’s position in the region. It strives to answer the question of how this change impacted the geopolitical power balance for Russia. The author used the historical events’ analysis method as well as examined both official information and the opinions of independent experts before attempting to make the most important provisions by comparing, contrasting and analysing these frequently diametrically opposed forecasts and opinions. The author argues that, contrary to some speculations, the situation might have changed not in favour of Russia in the longer run. The Karabakh war of 2020 highlighted the competition between regional powers, including Turkey, in the region and beyond. As a result of the war of 2020, Russia was able to station its peacekeepers in Nagorno-Karabakh but also had to count with Turkey’s substantial influence over the region, which has a tendency to expand to Central Asia and Northern Caucasus. To withstand the regional competition Moscow has charted a policy to foster economic cooperation projects between warring states, to enhance internal cohesion in this post-USSR territory under its guidance. This will allow Russia to transform the South Caucasus into a more or less stable region that will be its buffer belt, with guaranteed non-hostile regimes.
References
Akonov P. (2020), Pochemu Putin nazval Erdogana nadezhnym partnerom, 24.10.2020, “Ria Novosti”, https://ria.ru/20201024/partner-1581260494.html.
All-Union population census, (1928), Narodnost‘ i rodnoj jazyk naselenija SSSR, ed. 4, p. 127, http://elib.shpl.ru/ru/nodes/16537-vyp-4-narodnost-i-rodnoy-yazyk-naseleniya-sssr-1928#mode/inspect/page/163/zoom/6.
Amirbek A., Aydin T. (2015), Identity Politics of Turkey Towards Central Asia, “Mediterranean Journal of Social Sciences”, vol. 6, no. 6 S2, pp. 21–25.
ANI (2016), Madridskiye Printsipy – Polnyy Tekst, 12.04.2006, “ANI Armenian Research Center”, http://www.aniarc.am/2016/04/12/madrid-document-full-russian/.
Avdaliani E. (2021), Turkey’s Return to Central Asia, “Royal United Services Institute”, https://rusi.org/explore-our-research/publications/commentary/turkeys-return-central-asia/.
Barabanov M. S., Lavrov A. V., Lomov N. A., Lyamin YU. YU., Nersisyan L. A., Nikol’skiy A. V., Seren M., Topchiy I. A., Yesiltas M., ed. Makiyenko K. (2018), V ozhidanii buri: Yuzhnyy Kavkaz, Tsentr analiza strategiy i tekhnologiy, Moscow.
Barri D., Derlug‘yan G. M., Iskandaryan A. M., Kazalet M., Lavrov A. V., Makiyenko K. V., Markedonov S. M., Nersisyan L. A., Pukhov R. N., Trenin D. V., Khas K., Shepovalenko M. YU., ed. Pukhova R. N. (2021), Burya na Kavkaze, Tsentr analiza strategiy i tekhnologiy, Moscow.
Baunov A. (2020), V ozhidanii soyuznika. Pochemu Rossiya ne speshit pomogat‘ Armenii v Karabakhe, 8.10.2020, “Carnegie Moscow Center”, https://carnegie.ru/commentary/82921.
Berezko V. (2007), Lenin i Stalin: Taynyye pruzhiny vlasti gosudarstvenno – pravovaya ideologiya levogo avtoritarizma, Moskva, https://mgimo.ru/upload/iblock/52e/52e1e5bb4fe74e4e176fcda6f2b2f12b.pdf.
Broers L. (2020), Perspectives | New Armenian-Azerbaijani war forces Russia to make tough choices, 5.10.2020, “eurasianet”, https://eurasianet.org/perspectives-new-armenian-azerbaijani-war-forces-russia-to-make-tough-choices.
Brzezinski Z. (1997), The grand chessboard: American primacy and its geostrategic imperatives, BasicBooks, New York, NY.
Budberg A. (2020), Azerbaydzhan medlenno budet prodvigat’sya vpered, 15.10.2020, “Vestnik Kavkaza”, https://vestikavkaza.ru/analytics/aleksandr-budberg-azerbajdzan-medlenno-budet-prodvigatsa-vpered.html.
Cavanaugh C. (2017), Renewed Conflict Over Nagorno-Karabakh, 21.02.2017, “Council on Foreign Relations”, https://www.cfr.org/report/renewed-conflict-over-nagorno-karabakh.
Central Electoral Commission of the Republic of Artsakh (1991), Referendum, http://cecnkr.am/.
Cherkasov A. (2020), Raschelovechivaniye i osobaya pozitsiya RT. Kak voynu v Karabakhe pokazyvayut v Armenii, Azerbaydzhane, Rossii i Turtsii, 3.10.2020, “Nastoyashcheye Vremya”, https://www.currenttime.tv/a/armenia-azerbaijan-turkey-russia-media/30868737.html.
Cheterian V. (2011), War and Peace in the Caucasus: Russia’s Troubled Frontier, Hurst & Company, London.
de Waal T. (2021), The Nagorny Karabakh Conflict in its fourth decade, CEPS Working Document, no. 2021-02, https://www.ceps.eu/wp-content/uploads/2021/09/WD2021-02_The-Nagorny-Karabakh-Conflict-in-its-Fourth-Decade.pdf.
de Waal T. (2018), Rossiya i karabakhskoye uregulirovaniye: strategiya-minimum, 22.02.2018, “Carnegie Moscow Center”, https://carnegie.ru/commentary/75616.
Detsch J. (2021), The U.S. Army Goes to School on Nagorno-Karabakh Conflict, 30.03.2021, “FP”, https://foreignpolicy.com/2021/03/30/army-pentagon-nagorno-karabakh-drones/.
Grono M. (2016), The Shifting Dangers of Nagorno-Karabakh, 26.02.2016, “Crisis Group”, https://www.crisisgroup.org/europe-central-asia/caucasus/nagorno-karabakh-azerbaijan/shifting-dangers-nagorno-karabakh.
Guliyev D. P. (1989), K istorii obrazovaniya Nagorno-Karabakhskoy Avtonomnoy oblasti Azerbaydzhanskoy SSR: 1918–1925: dokumenty i materialy, “studmed.ru”, https://www.studmed.ru/view/guliev-dp-redaktor-k-istorii-obrazovaniya-nagorno-karabahskoy-avtonomnoy-oblasti-azerbaydzhanskoy-ssr-1918-1925-dokumenty-i-materialy_31bf4304215.html?page=6.
Gurbanov I. (2019), Military Procurements on Armenia’s and Azerbaijan’s Defense Agendas, 27.03.2019, “The Central Asia-Caucasus ANALYST”, https://cacianalyst.org/publications/analytical-articles/item/13564-military-procurements-on-armenias-and-azerbaijans-defense-agendas.html.
Hecht E. (2022), Drones in the Nagorno-Karabakh War: Analyzing the Data, “Military Strategy Magazine”, https://www.militarystrategymagazine.com/article/drones-in-the-nagorno-karabakh-war-analyzing-the-data/.
Hill F., Kari K., Moffatt A. (2015), Retracing the Caucasian Circle – considerations and constraints for U. S., EU, and Turkish engagement in the South Caucasus, Turkey Project Policy Paper, no. 6, Center on the United States and Europe at Brookings, https://www.brookings.edu/wp-content/uploads/2016/06/south_caucasus.pdf.
Isachenko D. (2020), Turkey-Russia Partnership in the War over Nagorno-Karabakh, 19.11.2020, “Stiftung Wissenschaft und Politik”, https://www.swp-berlin.org/10.18449/2020C53/.
Iskandaryan A. (2021), The Epoch of Regional Powers: Why Russia Lost and Turkey Won in Nagorno-Karabakh, 15.11.2021, “PONARS Eurasia”, https://www.ponarseurasia.org/the-epoch-of-regional-powers-why-russia-lost-and-turkey-won-in-nagorno-karabakh/.
Izvestiya IZ (2021), V Kremle prokommentirovali foto Erdogana s kartoy tyurkskogo mira, 21.11.2021, “Izvestiya IZ”, https://iz.ru/1253102/2021-11-21/v-kremle-prokommentirovali-foto-erdogana-s-kartoi-tiurkskogo-mira.
Kaleji V. (2021), The 2020 Karabakh War’s Impact on the Northwestern Border of Iran, 26.08.2021, “Jamestown Foundation”, https://jamestown.org/program/the-2020-karabakh-wars-impact-on-the-northwestern-border-of-iran/.
Khitakhunov A. (2022), Trade between Turkey and Central Asia, “Eurasian Research Institute”, https://www.eurasian-research.org/publication/trade-between-turkey-and-central-asia/.
Kocharyan R. (2020), Nagornyy Karabakh: zhizn’ i svoboda na grani voyny, 30.09.2020, “Rossiya v global’noy politike”, https://globalaffairs.ru/articles/nagornyj-karabah-zhizn-na-grani-vojny/.
Kortunov A. (2020), Odna takticheskaya pobeda i shest’ strategicheskikh, 16.11.2020, “Rossiyskiy sovet po mezhdunarodnym delam”, https://russiancouncil.ru/analytics-and-comments/analytics/odna-takticheskaya-pobeda-i-shest-strategicheskikh-vyzovov/.
Kvashonkin A. V. (1997), Sovetizatsiya Zakavkaz’ya v perepiske bol’shevistskogo rukovodstva, 1920–1922 gg., “Cahiers du Monde Russe”, vol. 38, no. 1–2, pp. 163–194.
Markedonov S. (2018), Nagornyy Karabakh — 2018: voyna, mir ili balansirovaniye na grani?, “Rossiyskiy sovet po mezhdunarodnym delam”, 17.01.2018, https://russiancouncil.ru/analytics-and-comments/analytics/nagornyy-karabakh-2018-voyna-mir-ili-balansirovanie-na-grani/.
Meister S. (2021), Shifting Geopolitical Realities in the South Caucasus, Utrikespolitiska Instituet, https://www.ui.se/forskning/centrum-for-osteuropastudier/sceeus-report/shifting-geopolitical-realities-in-the-south-caucasus/.
MFA (2022), Nagorno-Karabakhskaya problema, “Ministerstvo inostrannykh del Respubliki Armeniya”, https://www.mfa.am/ru/nagorno-karabakh-issue.
National Assembly of the Republic of Armenia (2022), Bishkekskyi protokol, “Hayastani Hanrapetut’yan Azgayin zhoghov”, http://www.parliament.am/library/LGH/doc_9.pdf.
NKR (2022), Karabakh in 1988: The beginning of the modern stage of national-liberation struggle, “Ministry for Foreign Affairs, Republic of Artsakh”, http://www.nkr.am/en/karabakh-national-liberation-movement.
O’Byrne D. (2021), Azerbaijan and Turkmenistan Agreement Advances Caspian Gas Cooperation, “Eurasianet”, 22.01.2021, https://eurasianet.org/azerbaijan-and-turkmenistan-agreement-advances-caspian-gas-cooperation.
OHCHR (2020), Mercenaries in and around the Nagorno-Karabakh conflict zone must be withdrawn – UN experts, 11.11.2020, https://www.ohchr.org/EN/NewsEvents/Pages/DisplayNews.aspx?NewsID=26494.
Public International Law & Policy Group and New England Center for International Law & Policy (2000), The Nagorno-Karabagh Crisis: A Blueprint for Resolution, https://deliverypdf.ssrn.com/delivery.php?ID=2261250901170060710701120211131240650520570470320950571231
Shaikh S., Rumbaugh W. (2020), The Air and Missile War in Nagorno-Karabakh: Lessons for the Future of Strike and Defense, 8.12.2020, “CSIS”, https://www.csis.org/analysis/air-and-missile-war-nagorno-karabakh-lessons-future-strike-and-defense.
Shahbazov F. (2021), The Second Karabakh War and Caspian Energy, 19.04.2021, “The Central Asia-Caucasus ANALYST”, https://www.cacianalyst.org/publications/analytical-articles/item/13668-the-second-karabakh-war-and-caspian-energy.html.
Smith J., Wezeman P. D., Kuimova A. (2021), Arms transfers to conflict zones: The case of Nagorno-Karabakh, 30.04.2021, “SIPRI”, https://www.sipri.org/commentary/topical-backgrounder/2021/arms-transfers-conflict-zones-case-nagorno-karabakh.
Sprengel F. C. (2021), Drones in hybrid warfare: Lessons from current battlefields, COI Strategy and Defence, Hybrid CoE Working Paper 10, https://www.hybridcoe.fi/wp-content/uploads/2021/06/20210611_Hybrid_CoE_Working_Paper_10_Drones_in_hybrid_warfare_WEB.pdf.
Strokan’ S. (2020), Karabakhskaya voyna vse blizhe k Rossii, 1.11.2020, “Kommersant”, https://www.kommersant.ru/doc/4557408.
Stronski P. (2021), Bol‘she, chem postsovetskiy: novyy geopoliticheskiy landshaft Yuzhnogo Kavkaza, 23.09.2021, “Carnegie Moscow Center”, https://carnegie.ru/2021/09/23/ru-pub-85402.
Sysoyev T. (2021), Voyna v Karabakhe – eto tol’ko chast’ bol’shogo protivostoyaniya mezhdu Rossiyey i Turtsiyey, 18.10.2021, “Ekspert”, https://expert.ru/expert/2021/43/voyna-v-karabakhye-eto-tolko-chast-bolshogo-protivostoyaniya-mezhdu-rossiyey-i-turtsiyey/.
Tamrazian H. (2021), De Waal: Russia Is Playing A Long Game In Armenian-Azerbaijani Conflict, 23.08.2021, “Azatutyun”, https://www.azatutyun.am/a/31423368.html.
Tarasov S. (2011), Kak Stalin “sdal” Karabakh Azerbaydzhanu, 6.08.2011, “IA REGNUM”, https://regnum.ru/news/1432940.html.
TASS (2020), Stepanakert vnov’ popal pod obstrely, 17.10.2020, https://tass.ru/mezhdunarodnaya-panorama/9745455.
Topchin I. (2020), Karabah-2020: Voenno-politicheskij razbor. 50 tezisov o vojne Azerbajdzhana i Armenii. Pochemu pala oborona Karabaha, 23–29.11.2020, “Ekspert”, nr. 48,
Trenin D. (2021a), Post-Imperium: A Eurasian Story, Carnegie Endowment for International Peace, Washington.
Trenin D. (2021b), Rossiya i Zakavkaz’ye cherez god posle voyny v Karabakhe. Poslesloviye k knige “Burya na Kavkaze”, 9.11.2021, “Carnegie Moscow Center”, https://carnegie.ru/commentary/85683.
RBC.ru (2004), Press-konferentsiya Vladimira Putina, 23.12.2004, “RBC.ru”, https://www.rbc.ru/politics/23/12/2004/5703b69d9a7947783a5a5f29.
RBC.ru (2021), Erdoganu vruchili kartu «Tyurkskogo mira» s polovinoy territorii Rossii, 17.11.2021, “RBC.ru”, https://www.rbc.ru/politics/17/11/2021/619555809a794771aa5f12da.
Zakvasin A., Komarova Ye. (2021), “Unikal’nyy primer effektivnogo vliyaniya”: chto izmenilos’ v Karabakhe cherez god posle zaklyucheniya trokhstoronnego soglasheniya, 10.11.2021, “Russian RT”, https://russian.rt.com/ussr/article/925907-trehstoronee-soglashenie-karabah-mirotvorcy.
Zhukovskaya N. (2015), Tyurkskiye i Mongol’skiye narody Rossii, 18.07.2015, “Mnogonatsional‘nyy Peterburg”, http://nacionalsoglasie.kmormp.gov.spb.ru/narody-rossii/tjurkskie-i-mongolskie-narody-rossii/#:~:text=На%20земном%20шаре%20в%20разных,численность%20около%2010%20млн%20человек.
Chapter Five: Russia and Eurasia (2020), “The Military Balance”, vol. 120, no. 1, pp. 166–219.