Musical sense-making between experience and conceptualisation: the legacy of Peirce, Dewey and James

Słowa kluczowe

musical sign
cognitive semantics
radical empiricism
continuous- discrete

Jak cytować

Reybrouck, M. (2018). Musical sense-making between experience and conceptualisation: the legacy of Peirce, Dewey and James. Interdisciplinary Studies in Musicology, (14), 192–205. Pobrano z


This contribution revolves around the concept of musical sense-making. Starting from the seminal works of Peirce, Dewey and James, it focusses on the musical experience, which can be defined from an empiricist position as a process that calls forth epistemic interactions with the sounds. Central in this approach is the tension between the richness and fullness of the musical experience and the cognitive economy of symbolic abstraction. Dewey, in particular, has stressed the role of having an experience proper as a kind of heightened vitality. James, on the contrary, has dealt with the distinction between percept and concept, stressing the role of knowledge-by-acquaintance as the kind of knowledge we have of something by its presentation to the senses. In what he coined as radical empiricism he states that the significance of concepts always consists in their relation to perceptual particulars, which, in turn, are embedded in a conceptual map. This map can be described in semiotic terms, which holds a symbolic approach to cognition to the extent that it is concerned with signs rather than with sensory realia. The question should be raised, however, as to the nature of these signs. There is, in fact, a critical distinction between internal and external semantics with signs referring primarily to themselves or to something external to the music. In an attempt to bring these claims together, it is argued that musical signs should provide a self-referential semantics for which the abstract is really material, a real semiotics of singular potential wich is grounded in the real and natural experience. Reying on some grounding work of Peirce and Morris and the relation between signs and tool using, a theoretical framework is introduced that has at least some operational power in going beyond a merely acoustic description of the music as it sounds.



Bense, Max. Zeichen und Design. Semiotische Ästhetik. Baden-Baden: Agis, 1971.

Boler, John. Charles Sanders Peirce and Scholastic Realism. A Study of Peirce’s Relation to John Duns Scotus. Seattle: University of Washington Press, 1963.

Bruner, Jerome, Goodnow, Jacqueline, Austin, George. A study of thinking. New York: Wiley, 1956.

Dewey, John. Experience and nature. Chicago - London: Open Court Publishing Company, 1925.

Dewey, John. Art as Experience. New York: Capricorn Books, 1958[1934].

Godoy, Rolf Inge. Formalization and Epistemology. Oslo: Scandinavian University Press, 1997.

Hartshorne, Charles, Weiss, Paul eds. Collected Papers o f Charles Sanders Peirce. Vol.V. Pragmatism and Pragmaticism and Vol.VI. Scientific Metaphysics. Cambridge: Harvard University Press, 1965.

Jackendoff, Ray. Consciousness and the Computational Mind. Cambridge, Mass - London: MIT Press, 1987.

James, William. Essays in Radical Empiricism. Cambridge, Mass - London: Harvard University Press, (1976[1912]).

Lakoff, George. Women, Fire, and Dangerous Things: What categories reveal About the Mind. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1987.

McCabe, Viki Balzano, Gerald. Event Cognition: An Ecological Perspective. Hillsdale, NJ - London: Lawrence Erlbaum, 1986.

Morris, Charles. Foundations o f the Theory o f Signs, Vol.l, nr.2, Chicago - London: University of Chicago Press, 1975 [1938], Neisser, Ulric. Cognitive Psychology. New York: Appleton-Century Crofts, 1976.

Morris, Charles. Cognition and reality. San Francisco: Freeman, 1976.

Peirce, Charles Sanders. “Elements of logic”. In. Collected papers o f Charles Sanders Peirce. Vol. 2., Edited by Charles Hartshorne and Paul Weiss. Cambridge, Mass: Harvard University Press, 1960.

Reybrouck, Mark. “The musical sign between sound and meaning”. Music and Signs, Semiotic and Cognitive Studies in Music. Edited by Iannis Zannos, 39-58. Bratislava: ASCO Art & Science, 1999.

Reybrouck, Mark. “Biological roots of musical epistemology: Functional Cycles, Umwelt, and enactive listening.” Semiotica 134, no. 1-4 (2001): 599-63.

Reybrouck, Mark. “A Biosemiotic and Ecological Approach to Music Cognition: Event Perception between Auditory Listening and Cognitive Economy.” Axiomathes. An International Journal in Ontology and Cognitive Systems 15, no. 2 (2005): 229-66.

Reybrouck, Mark. “Musical Creativity between Symbolic Modelling and Perceptual Constraints: the Role of Adaptive Behaviour and Epistemic Autonomy.” In Musical Creativity: Multidisciplinary Research in Theory and Practice. Edited by Irène Deliège and Geraint Wiggins, 42-59. Oxford: Psychology Press, 2006.

Reybrouck, Mark. “Similarity perception as a cognitive tool for musical sense-making: deictic and ecological claims.” Musicae Scientiae, Discussion Forum 4B (2009): 99-118.

Reybrouck, Mark. “Music cognition and real-time listening: denotation, cue abstraction, route description and cognitive maps.” Musicae Scientiae (Special Issue) (2010): 187-202.

Rosch, Eleanor, Barbara Lloyd, eds. Cognition and Categorization. Hillsdale, NY: Erlbaum, 1978.

Varela, Francisco, Thompson, Evan, Rosch, Eleanor. The Embodied Mind. Cognitive science and Human Experience. Cambridge, Mass - London: MIT Press, 1991.

Vygotsky, Lev. Thought and Language, Cambridge, Mass - London: MIT Press, 1962.

Vygotsky, Lev. Mind in Society. The Developpent o f Higher Psychological Processes. Cambridge, Mass - London: Harvard University Press, 1978.