Abstract
The main objective of the paper is to present the issues of the protection of internal security and constitutional order in view of the tasks and activities of the Internal Security Agency in Poland. The author of the text seeks answers to the following questions. (1) To what extent does the lack of clear-cut frames for the ISA’s activity influence the instrumental use of this agency? (2) Do over-generalised legal regulations on the ISA’s activities lead to poorer efficiency of this agency’s operations? (3) Does faulty regulation related to the ISA’s range of activities result from inadequacies in Polish legislation, or maybe from the intention to endow the special services with greater freedom of action?
In reference to the above questions, the author puts forward the following theses: (1) the selected and analysed legal instruments exert an infinitesimal influence on the scope of the application of “special measures”, such as the operational control or access to telecommunications data. Art. 3 of the Bill of 2014 contains too many vague terms or expressions whose legal definitions are missing from Polish legislation; (2) it seems reasonable that the range of the ISA’s activities has been restricted, e.g. as regards drug-related crime. However, other areas of the ISA’s interest have witnessed few changes, and its impromptu involvement with specific threats and offences is left to the ‘political decision’ of the Head of the ISA and the Minister of the Interior; (3) the impractical solutions are partly a result of an inadequate ‘legislative culture’, in this case, at the level of the Ministry of the Interior. This shortcoming might be the result of excessive haste during work on the Bill; nevertheless, such works always carry a political load, which means that the interests of the services themselves, as well as of the state, played an enormous role in this project.
References
Act of 24 May 2002 on the Internal Security Agency and Foreign Intelligence Agency (Journal of Laws 2002, No. 74, Item 676, as amended – consolidated text) [Abbr.: Act of 2002].
Act of 18 March 2010 on specific powers of the minister competent for the Treasury and on their execution in certain corporations or groups of companies engaged in business activity in the sectors of electricity, oil, and gaseous fuels (Journal of Laws No. 65, item 404).
Act of 6 June 1997 – Penal Code (Journal of Laws 1997, No. 88, item 553, as amended).
Act of 29 November 2000 on the international trade of commodities, technologies, and services of strategic importance for the security of the State as well as for the maintenance of peace and security (Journal of Laws of 2013, item 194).
Appraisal of the Bill on the Internal Security Agency carried out by the Head of the Central Anti-Corruption Bureau in the form of a letter to the Minister for the Interior of 19 August 2013 (2013).
Bożek M. (2014), The Position of Special Services in the System of State Authorities, in: Special Services in the Structure of Public Authorities. Legal and Political Issues (Usytuowanie służb specjalnych w systemie organów państwowych, in: Służby specjalne w strukturze władz publicznych. Zagadnienia prawnoustrojowe), eds. M. Bożek, M. Czuryk, M. Karpiuk, J. Kostrubiec, Wolters Kluwer, Warsaw.
Council Decision 2008/615/JHA of 23 June 2008 on the stepping up of cross-border co-operation, particularly in combating terrorism and cross-border crime.
Full Recording of a Conversation Belka–Sienkiewicz (Cała rozmowa Belki z Sienkiewiczem) (2014), http://www.wprost.pl/ar/452973/Cala-rozmowa-Belki-z-Sienkiewiczem/, 29.06.2014.
Grochwski R. (2013), The Role of Special Services in a Democratic State Based on the Rule of Law (Rola służb specjalnych w demokratycznym państwie prawa), “Środkoweuropejskie Studia Polityczne”, no. 4.
Grzemski J., Krześ A. (2010), An Analysis of a “Crime Infringing the Economic Fundaments of the State” in the Act of 24 may 2002 on the Internal Security Agency and Foreign Intelligence Agency (Analiza pojęcia “przestępstwa godzące w podstawy ekonomiczne państwa” w ustawie z dnia 24 maja 2002 r. o Agencji Bezpieczeństwa Wewnętrznego oraz Agencji Wywiadu), “Przegląd Bezpieczeństwa Wewnętrznego”, no. 2.
ISA’s activity report of 2011 (2012), ISA, Warsaw 2012 [Abbr.: Report, 2012].
ISA’s activity report of 2012 (2013), ISA, Warsaw 2013 [Abbr.: Report, 2013].
ISA’s activity report of 2013 (2014), ISA, Warsaw 2014 [Abbr.: Report, 2014].
Karpiuk M. (2014), The Scope of Activity of Special Services, in: Special Services in the Structure of Public Authorities. Legal and Political Issues (Zakres działania służb specjalnych, in: Służby specjalne w strukturze władz publicznych. Zagadnienia prawnoustrojowe), eds. M. Bożek, M. Czuryk, M. Karpiuk, J. Kostrubiec, Wolters Kluwer, Warsaw.
Kublik A., Czuchnowski W. (2008), Truly Short Course (Naprawdę szybki kurs), “Gazeta Wyborcza”, http://wyborcza.pl/1,76842,5153699.html, 16.08.2013.
Malinowski D. (2014), The Russians seized over 20% of Grupa Azoty shares (Rosjanie mają już ponad 20% akcji Grupy Azoty), http://chemia.wnp.pl/rosjanie-May-juz-ponad-20-proc-akcji-grupy-azoty,227754_1_0_0.html, 11.06.2014.
Prusak F. (2012), Special Services, in: Institutions of National Security (Służby specjalne, in: Instytucje bezpieczeństwa narodowego), eds. M. Paździor, B. Szmulik, C.H. Beck, Warsaw.
Regulation of the Council of Ministers of 20 June 2002 on the Principles of Legislative Technique (Journal of Laws of No. 100, item 908).
Rosicki R. (2014), Information Security as Exemplified by Clandestine Collaboration and Influence Exerted by the Polish Internal Security Agency Officers on Journalists – De Lege Lata and De Lege Ferenda Regulations, “Przegląd Strategiczny”, no. 7.
Rosicki R. (2013a), Opinion on the proposed reform of the secret services in Poland – the Bill on the Internal Security Agency (2013), http://www.jdsupra.com/legalnews/opinion-on-the-proposed-reform-of-the-se-49565/, 29.06.2014.
Rosicki R. (2013b), Panopticon – power, knowledge, and information (Panoptykon – władza, wiedza i informacja), “Przegląd Naukowo-Metodyczny. Edukacja dla Bezpieczeństwa”, no. 4.
Szymonik A. (2011), Organisation and Functioning of the Security Systems (Organizacja i funkcjonowanie systemów bezpieczeństwa), Difin, Warsaw.
The Bill on the Internal Security Agency submitted for consultation in 2013 [Abbr.: Bill of 2013].
The Bill on the Internal Security Agency with drafts implementing acts submitted to the Sejm by the Prime Minister in 2014 [Abbr.: Bill of 2014].
Wronkowska S., Ziembiński Z. (1997), An Outline Theory of Law (Zarys teorii prawa), Publishing House: Ars boni et aequi, Poznań.
Zawadka G. (2014), Several dozen people have been recorded (Nagrali kilkadziesiąt osób), “Rzeczpospolita” of 27.06.2014.
Żakowski J. (2014), The Truth Will Enslave You (Prawda was zniewoli), “Polityka”, no. 26.