O ciągłości celów wychowawczych i edukacyjnych – wyniki badań jakościowych przeprowadzonych na wychowawcach i nauczycielach przedmiotów w Izraelu

Słowa kluczowe

homeroom educators
subject teachers
educational aims
achievements' evaluation
role perception
inclusive practices

Jak cytować

Bar Gosen, N. . (2020). O ciągłości celów wychowawczych i edukacyjnych – wyniki badań jakościowych przeprowadzonych na wychowawcach i nauczycielach przedmiotów w Izraelu. Studia Edukacyjne, (42), 435–451. https://doi.org/10.14746/se.2016.42.25


This research project presents different role perceptions regarding educational and academic aims, among high school instruction personnel.
Since its foundation the Israeli education system has defined its role as a socialization agent as well as an academic institution. As national and international achievement tests became more widespread, the focus on academic aspect increased and the influence of academic excellence on school grading can be seen as more influential in comparison to educational achievements. Semi-structured interviews of 14 high school teachers – homeroom educators and subject teachers – were conducted. Results show that homeroom educators put more emphasis on educational aims while subject teachers put more emphasis on academic achievements. Their definition of success was a mixture of both objectives. Homeroom educators tend to apply educational inclusive practices
while subject teachers tend to apply instructional ones. International research emphasizes the importance of educational aims and inclusive practices in promoting academic achievements for all (OECD, 2010). The emphasis on evaluation and assessment of academic achievements may results in exclusive practices. These results suggest that adding educational achievements to schools' evaluation scales can encourage all instruction personnel to promote educational aims and inclusive practices as well as academic ones, thus contributing to schools' performance in evaluation tests.



Adar T., An Introduction to Education and Teaching, Gomeh – Science and Research books, Zerikover Pub., Tel Aviv 1974. (Hebrew)

Aloni N., Preface: The Philosophy as the Love of Wisdom and the Yearning for Comprehensive Understanding in the Art of Life, [in:] Becoming Human, Philosophy of Education: An An-thology, Ed. N. Aloni, Mofet Institute, Hakibutz Hmeochad Pub., Tel Aviv 2005, p. 74-84. (Hebrew)

Alboym-Dror R., The Hebrew Education in Eretz Yisrael, Yad Yitchak Ben Tzvy Pub., Jerusalem 1986. (Hebrew)

Bakshi-Bros U., The Significance of the Roles of Homeroom Educators and Subject Teachers in the Israeli Education System, Ben Gurion University of the Negev, Negev 2005. (Hebrew)

Bar Gosen N., Different Role Perceptions and Student – Teacher Relationship characteristics Among High School Homeroom Educators and Subject Teachers' Results from a Qualitataive Research, Studia Edukacyjne, 2015, 36, p. 381-400.

Bogdan R.C., Biklen S.K., Qualitative Research for Education – an Introduction to Theories and Methods, 5th edition, Pearson Education Inc., U.S.A. 2007.

Bowels S., Gints H., Schooling in Capitalistic America, Educational Reforms and the Construc-tion of Economic life, Basic Books Inc., New York 1977.

Brint S., School and Societies, Stanford, California 2006.

Carmon M., The Teachers' Organization and the Education Problem in the 'Yishuv' (prior to the establishment of the state of Israel – N.BG), Israeli teachers organization Jubilee Book, Eds. D. Kimhi, L.Y. Riklis, 1956. (Hebrew)

Carrington S., Elkins J., Bridging the gap between inclusive policy and inclusive culture in secondary schools. Support for Learning, A Journal for the National Association from Special Educational Needs, 2002, 17(2).

David K., The North Says Yes to the IDF; http://www.mynet.co.il/articles/0,7340,L-3999693,00.html [Access: August, 2015]. (Hebrew)

David K., Kibutzim and Moahavim's Youth Favors the Army MyNet http://www.mynet.co.il/articles/0,7340,L-3999693,00.html [Access: May, 2016]. (Hebrew)

Gordon D., Ackerman W.I., The Mechanech: Role Function and Myth in Israeli secondary Schools, Comparative Education Review, 1984, 28, 1.

Higginbothan P.J., Philosophy and the Teacher, 1st pub., Routledge and Kegan Paul, London– Henley – Boston 1976, Ch. 4.

Kleinberger A., Society, Schools and Progress in Israel, Pergamon Press, Oxford 1969.

Korczak J., The Child Religion, Bet Lochamey Hagetaot and Hakibutz Hameochad Pub., Israel 1978. (Hebrew)

Ministry of Education, MATANA (Planning, administration, and preparation package for 2015/2016), Pedagogic Administration. (Hebrew) http://cms.education.gov.il/

EducationCMS/Units/MinhalPedagogi/matana/2015.htm [access: May 2016].

Ministry of Education, Teaching staff work regulations. (Hebrew) http://cms.education.gov.il/EducationCMS/UNITS/Sherut/Takanon [access: January, 2015].

Mor F., Seeing the Children – Guide to Creating a Nurturing Educational –Therapeutic Envi-ronment for At-risk Students, Ashalim, Ministry of Education, Jerusalem 2006. (Hebrew)

Noddings N., The Challenge to Care in Schools an Alternative Approach to Education, Teachers College Press, Columbia University, New York – London 1992.

Notov L., Homeroom educator LTD, Litam Pub., Israel 2006. (Hebrew)

Notov L., What is Between Maslow and Scehin? Organizational Engagement Model as an Ex-pression of Culture, Needs and Management: The Case of Role design of the Israeli High School Homeroom Teacher, Doctoral dissertation, Technion, Haifa 2011. (Hebrew)

Oakeshott M., Learning and Teaching, [in:] The Concept of Education, Ed. R.S. Peters, Routledge and Kegan Paul, London 1966.

OECD, PISA 2009, Results: overcoming social background', Equity in Learning Opportunities and Outcomes', vol. 5.

OECD, PISA 2012, Results: Ready to Learn – Students’ Engagement, Drive and Self-Beliefs, OECD Publishing, 2013.

OECD, Strong Performers and Successful Reformers in Education: Lessons from PIZA for the United States. 2010, http://dx.doi.org 10/1787/9789264096660-en [access: 2013].

Raichel N., The Story of the Israeli Education System, Between Centralism and Distribution, Clarity and Ambiguity, Replication and Ingenuity, Mofet Institute Pub., Israel 2008. (Hebrew)

Rama (Israel National Authority for Measurement and Evaluation in Education), Ministry of Education, Israel 2016. (Hebrew)

Razer M., Mittelberg D., Motola M., Bar Gosen N., Inclusion and Achievement in Education: Contradictory or Complementary Goals? Dvarim Oranim College, 2013, 6. (Hebrew)

Razer M., Mittelberg D., Motola M., Bar Gosen N., Israeli high school teachers’ perceptions and attitudes towards a pedagogy of inclusion, International Journal of Inclusive Education, 2015.

Sela A., Text-Books and Text people' What is the Role of the Mechanech in the Jewish Secular High School in Israel, and what is the Place of the Jewish Texts Within That Role? Doctoral dissertation, William Davidson Graduate School of Jewish Education, New York 2011.

Silbert Y., The teacher's professional status in Eretz Yisrael 1892-1913, Tel Aviv University, Tel Aviv 1995, p. 45-58. (Hebrew)

Sherman S., Responsiveness in Teaching: Responsibility in its Most Particular Sense, The Educational Forum, 2004, 68.

Smith F., Harison A.S., Principles of Class Teaching, Hadar Pub., Tel Aviv 1958. (Hebrew)

Tadmor Y., Homeroom Teachers as Key Figures in Education, [in:] Words That Teach: Collected

Lectures and Articles, Ed. Y. Tadmor, Kedem Pub., Tel Aviv 1999, p. 200-217. (Hebrew)

Tadmor-Shimon T., National education and formation of state in Israel, Negev 2010.

Walla! News. Where do most moral and ethical high school students in Israel study? http://news.walla.co.il/item/2880263 [entry: 11.8.2015].

Wentzel K.P., Are Affective Teachers Are Like Good Parents? Teaching Styles and Student Achievements in Early Adolescence, Child Development, 2002, 73, 1, p. 287-301.

Yair G., Inbar D., Achievements' standardization in education: a check point, a mile stone or an obstacle, [in:] Toward Educational Evolution? Ed. D. Inbar, Van Leer Institute, Jerusalem 2006.

Yin R.K., Qualitative Research from Start to Finish, Guilford Press, New York 2011.

Zidkiyaho S., Elam N., Fisherman S., Ronen H., Classroom Management, Mofet Institute 2008. (Hebrew)