Pedagogical Beliefs of Arab Mathematics and Religion Teachers in Northern Israel

Słowa kluczowe

pedagogical beliefs
mathematics teachers
religion teachers
Arab teachers

Jak cytować

Chen Goldberg, C. G., & Ishan, G. . (2020). Pedagogical Beliefs of Arab Mathematics and Religion Teachers in Northern Israel. Studia Edukacyjne, (58), 279–290.


The aim of the current study is to examine the relationship between the pedagogical beliefs of teachers and their profession and to examine how this relationship affects teachers’ self-efficacy perception, satisfaction, and other functional characteristics of the teacher within the educational system. More specifically, the study seeks to compare the pedagogical beliefs of Muslim teachers who teach Religion subjects (i.e. Islamic studies) and the pedagogical beliefs of teachers of secular studies (i.e. Mathematics). According to the proposed research model, the teaching profession (that is, teaching religious Islam or teaching Mathematics) divergently affects the nature of teachers’ pedagogical beliefs, through which they function and perceive their role as teachers. The focus of our study is Arab teachers of Islam versus Arab mathematics teachers, who reflect traditional pedagogical beliefs on two levels, first by selecting teachers belonging to the Muslim minority in Israel, but also in the context of the distinction between teaching. The study hypothesis suggests that there is a difference between the pedagogical beliefs of teachers of Islamic studies and the pedagogical beliefs of Mathematics teachers. In particular, it seeks to examine the claim that teachers of Islamic studies will have a strong traditional belief and weaker constructive belief compared to teachers of secular studies. This research hypothesis has not been confirmed. In fact, except in terms of teachers’ satisfaction, no differences between the two types of teachers were found. This might indicate a change in the Arab society which deviates from the traditional Islamic halakhic approach that focuses almost entirely on religious studies and adopts a more modernized and liberal educational approach, centered on a Western education model and secularism.


Anderson S.E., Groulx J.G., Maninger R.M., Relationships among preservice teachers’ technology- related abilities, beliefs, and intentions to use technology in their future classrooms, Journal of Educational Computing Research, 2011, 45, 3.

Barnes N., Fives H., Dacey C.M., Teachers’ beliefs about assessment, International Handbook of Research on Teachers’ Beliefs, 2015.

Barrett S.E., The Impact of Religious Beliefs on Professional Ethics: A Case Study of a New Teacher, Canadian Journal of Education; Toronto, 2015, 38, 3.

Batool S., Farooqi M.T.K., Islam M.U., Measuring Teachers’ Job Satisfaction: A Locale and Gender

Based Comparison of Secondary School Teachers, International Journal of Innovation in Teaching and Learning (IJITL), Dicembre 2018, 4, 1;

Bishay A., Teacher motivation and job satisfaction: A study employing the experience sampling method, Journal of Undergraduate Sciences, 1996, 3, 3.

Carmeli A., Freund A., Work commitment, job satisfaction, and job performance: An empirical investigation, International Journal of Organization Theory & Behavior, 2003, 7, 3.

Central Bureau of Statistics, Teaching Staff in Secondary Education by Selected Characteristics, Yearly census report, Jerusalem, Israel, Central Bureau of Statistics, 2019 (in Hebrew).

Chan Y.-C., Wong N.-Y., Worldviews, religions, and beliefs about teaching and learning: perception of mathematics teachers with different religious backgrounds, Educational Studies in Mathematics, 2014, 87, 3.

Cullen T.A., Greene B.A., Preservice teachers’ beliefs, attitudes, and motivation about technology integration, Journal of Educational Computing Research, 2011, 45, 1.

Evers W.J.G., Tomic W., Brouwers A., Burnout among Teachers Students’ and Teachers’ Perceptions Compared, School Psychology International, maggio 2004, 25, 2.

Faigen N., Talmor R., Erlich A., The eroding combination: Factors of erosion in the work of physical education teachers in classrooms that integrate pupils with special needs, Trends, 2004, 43, 3, (in Hebrew).

Fisher Y., Exploration of values: Israeli teachers’ professional ethics, Social Psychology of Education, 2013, 16, 2.

Fives H., Exploring the relationships of teachers’ efficacy, knowledge, and pedagogical beliefs: A multimethod study, PhD Thesis, University of Maryland, 2003.

Fives H., Gill M.G., International handbook of research on teachers’ beliefs, Routledge, 2014.

Friedman Y., Kass A., Teachers’ self-efficacy: concept and measurement, A series of research tools, Jerusalem, Sald Institution, 2001 (in Hebrew).

Gagné M., Forest J., Gilbert M.-H., Aubé C., Morin E., Malorni A., The Motivation at Work

Scale: Validation Evidence in Two Languages, Educational and Psychological Measurement, agosto 2010, 70, 4.

Hui A.N., Shek D.T., Wu J.K., Wu M.J., Chan L.K., Do Demographic Characteristics Make a Difference to Psychological Well-Being among Secondary School Teachers in Hong Kong?,

th Annual Meeting International Society for Quality-of-Life Studies: “Promotion of Quality of Life in the Changing World”, 2018.

Ilues S., The pedagogical beliefs of Bible and the Oral Law teachers of girls in the religious high school, PhD Thesis, Ramat-Gan, Bar-Ilan University, 2004 (in Hebrew).

Kunter M., Tsai Y.-M., Klusmann U., Brunner M., Krauss S., Baumert J., Students’ and mathematics teachers’ perceptions of teacher enthusiasm and instruction, Learning and Instruction, 2008, 18, 5.

Kupfferberg I., Niederland D., To be a teacher in Israel in the 21st century, [in:] Building Professional Identity: Professional training and development processes for teachers in Israel, Eds. R. Kloyer, L. Kozminsky, Tel Aviv, Moffett Institute, 2012 (in Hebrew).

Lamoureux K., Strategic Onboarding: Transforming New Hires into Dedicated Employees, Besrin & Associates Research Bulletin, 2008, 3, 1.

Leijen Ä., Pedaste M., Pedagogical Beliefs, Instructional Practices, and Opportunities for Professional Development of Teachers in Estonia, The Teacher’s Role in the Changing Globalizing World, maggio 2018.

Mahajhna A., Kfir D., Islamic Studies in the Age of Globalization: The Case of Arab Teacher Training in Israel, Beit Berl Academic College, 2012 (in Hebrew).

Mihaela V., Alina-Oana B., (When) Teachers’ Pedagogical Beliefs are Changing?, Procedia-Social and Behavioral Sciences, 2015, 180.

Ministry of Education, Opening 2019-2020 school year public announcement by Israel’s Education minister, (in Hebrew), 2019;

OECD, Chapter 4: Teaching practices, teacher’s beliefs and attitudes, Creating Effective Teaching and Learning Environments: First Results from TALIS, OECD publications, 2009.

Peterson R.A., A Case Study of Grade 12 International School Students’ Perceptions of The Impact of a Bible Curriculum and the Teachers’ Delivery of that Bible Curriculum in a Christian International School, A Dissertation Presented in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree Doctor of Education, Lynchburg, VA, Liberty University, 2017.

Schrum L., Niederhauser D.S., Strudler N., Competencies, Challenges, and Changes: A US Perspective on Preparing Twenty-First Century Teachers and Leaders, [in:] Competencies in Teaching, Learning and Educational Leadership in the Digital Age: Papers from CELDA 2014, Eds. J.M. Spector, D. Ifenthaler, D.G. Sampson, P. Isaias (a cura di), Cham, Springer International Publishing, 2016;

Steiner K.D., Teachers’ Pedagogical Beliefs as Predictors of Teacher Burnout, Stanislaw Juszczyk, 2014.

Veissblei E., Vieneger A., The Education System in Israel – Selected Issues in the Field of the Knesset’s Education, Culture and Sports Committee, Special report to Education, Culture, and Sport committee, Israel Knesset, 2015 (in Hebrew).

Wang K., Chen Z., Luo W., Li Y., Waxman H., Examining the Differences between the Job Satisfaction of STEM and Non-STEM Novice Teachers with Leaving Intentions, EURASIA Journal of Mathematics, Science and Technology Education, 2018, 14, 6.