Mental Revival of Ukraine: A Stranger Among Friends?
PDF

Keywords

political mentality
mental revival
waves of migration
occupation
collaborationism
internal migrants
IDPs
universalism
Karpman drama triangle

How to Cite

Lavrynenko, H., & Donaj, Łukasz. (2023). Mental Revival of Ukraine: A Stranger Among Friends?. Central European Political Studies, (2), 51–69. https://doi.org/10.14746/ssp.2023.2.3

Abstract

The authors of the study analyze the problem of the mental revival of Ukrainians in the post-war period, as well as consequences of the division of society into the categories of “friends” and “strangers”. The authors distinguish three stages in which the Ukrainian society distanced itself from Soviet political system values in the transition from homo soveticus to the modern Ukrainian political mentality: political distillation, sublimation and calcination. Two waves of internal migrants in independent Ukraine have been identified: the first in 2014–2015, and the second and after February 24, 2022. The study focuses on the profession as an indicator for the level of political awareness among citizens. It is noted that since the beginning of the hybrid war, there has been a division of Ukrainian society into those who left and those who remained to live under occupation. The attention is also paid to the importance of understanding the motivation and behavior of these people, as well as reasons for making decisions in favor of or against cooperation with the occupants. The issue of potential and existing manifestations of collaboration in the occupied territories is analyzed. By using the “triangle of power and relations by Stephen Karpman”, the article examines general sentiments of Ukrainians on the division of their society into “friends” (“heroes”) and “strangers” (“traitors”) during military operations in Ukraine. The authors analyze communication and behavior types of citizens within three models: “victim”, “traitor” and “hero”. The study indicates that citizens who were and were not in the occupied territory are wary of each other; several scenarios of relations between them are identified. The first is acceptance as “friends”, a manifestation of compassion, a tolerant attitude, and willingness to help the “victim”. Another scenario is non-acceptance by the community, assignment to the category of “stranger”, and tense and suspicious attitude towards the “traitor”. The authors note that, in the post-war period, another division of society is likely to be observed, but not on the basis of the language or territory, but on the actual place of residence of citizens (in territories occupied or controlled by Ukraine) during hostilities.

https://doi.org/10.14746/ssp.2023.2.3
PDF

References

Are there “good Russians”? Examples of Germans who helped defeat Nazism (both at the front and on the home front) (2022), https://news.zerkalo.io/cellar/27866.html, 12.03.2023.

Are Ukrainians ready to give up the occupied territories to Russia for peace? (2022), https://novy.tv/ua/news/2022/05/24/chy-gotovi-ukrayinczi-viddaty-okupovani-terytoriyi-rosiyi-zarady-myru-opytuvannya/, 4.04.2023.

Barnes B. (2000), Understanding Agency. Social Theory and Responsible Action, London. DOI: https://doi.org/10.4135/9781446219140

Besiedina T. P. (2000), The specificity of the Ukrainian mentality: the linguistic aspect, “Science. Religion. Society”, vol. 2.

Carpathians are advised to be vigilant (2014), “Halychyna”, 1.07.2014.

Demianenko V. (2002), Mental Characteristics of the Political Consciousness of Ukrainians, “Human and Politics”, vol. 1.

Edele M. (2017), Stalin’s Defectors. How Red Army Soldiers became Hitler’s Collaborators, 1941–1945, Oxford. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1093/oso/9780198798156.001.0001

Ella Libanova on the future baby boom, migration, and the impact of war on the inferiority complex (2023), https://kp.ua/ua/life/a662465-ella-libanova-pro-majbutnij-bebi-bum-mihratsiju-ta-vpliv-vijni-na-kompleks-menshovartosti, 20.01.2023.

Fuchik Yu. (1946), Reporting with a noose around your neck, “New World”, no. 12.

Holovakha Ye. (2023), The war has led to processes that Ukrainians could not imagine, https://apostrophe.ua/ua/article/politics/2023-02-26/voyna-privela-k-tem-protsessam-kotoryie-ne-predstavlyali-ukraintsyi--evgeniy-golovaha/50675, 28.02.2023.

How to restore trust between IDPs and host communities: a study (2023), https://hromadske.radio/publications/yak-povernuty-doviru-mizh-pereselentsiamy-ta-hromadamy-shcho-ikh-pryymaiut-doslidzhennia, 9.04.2023.

Hrytsak J. (1998), National Identities in Post-Soviet Ukraine: The Case of L’viv and Donetsk, “Harvard Ukrainian Studies”, Cultures and Nations of Central and Eastern Europe, vol. 22.

Internally Displaced Persons (2022), https://r2p.org.ua/internally-displaced-persons/?lang=en, 13.04.2023.

It became known how many filtration camps were created by the occupiers (2022), https://lenta.ua/stalo-vidomo-skilki-filtratsiynih-taboriv-stvorili-okupanti-124358/, 8.01.2023.

Kalina N. F. (1999), Political Mentality: Structure or Rhizome?, Scientific research in social and political psychology, Kyiv.

Karpman’s triangle: methods of elaboration (2021), https://chronos.mg/blog/treugolnik-karpmana/, 21.02.2023.

Kovalevska Ye. (2022), “We were preparing Kherson for liberation”. How the resistance movement worked in Kherson region, BBC News Ukraine, https://www.bbc.com/ukrainian/news-63626171, 21.01.2023.

Krasotkina N. (2021), Children are the greatest happiness and joy in life, http://krasotkina.com/, 25.04.2023.

Kutsenko O. (2022), Sociostructural changes in society during the war: opportunities, threats, dilemmas, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6AbkK2SLKUE&ab_channel=AcademicSociology, 18.03.2023.

Libanova E. (2022), Why won’t all Ukrainians return home after the war?, https://www.radiosvoboda.org/a/libanova-demografichna-sytuatsiya-viyna-ukrayina-rosiya/32191691.html, 4.01.2023.

Makhalova I. (2019), Heroes or Perpetrators? How Soviet Collaborators received Red Army Medals, “The Journal of Slavic Military Studies”, vol. 32, no. 2. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/13518046.2019.1618634

Martynenko T. (2013), Ukrainian Auxiliary Police in the Lviv-City District: Strokes to a Special Portrait, “Bulletin of Lviv University”, Series: Historical, vol. 48.

Motrevich V. P. (2007), Activities of the MGB in the first postwar years to identify ex-politsayers and German collaborators, Question marks in the history of Ukraine: the regional dimension of Ukrainian history. Collection of materials of III International conference, Nizhyn, Publishing house of M. Gogol Nizhyn State University.

Nyvnia H. (2023), The problem of reintegration: world experience, Crimea is Ukraine: a strategy of deoccupation and reintegration. Materials of the International Scientific and Practical Round Table, Yurydyka Publishing House, Odesa.

Ortega y Gasset J. (1994), Selected works, Osnovy, Kyiv.

Patlakh I. M. (2002), An Interdisciplinary Model for the Study of Discourses of the National Mentality, “Human and Politics”, vol. 1.

Polishchuk I. O. (2002), The Mentality of Ukrainians: the Political Aspect, “Human and Politics”, vol. 1.

Probyiholova N. (2004), Features of the development of the theory of political socialization, “Political management”, vol. 6.

Prymush M., Lavrynenko H. (2020), Political identity as a security factor of Ukrainian statehood, “Przegląd Strategiczny”, Х(13). DOI: https://doi.org/10.14746/ps.2020.1.18

Readiness for territorial concessions to end the war as soon as possible: results of a telephone survey (2022), Kyiv International Institute of Sociology, https://www.kiis.com.ua/?lang=ukr&cat=reports&id=1111&page=1&fbclid=IwAR0BaueNoGh8t0mEjBiBmJo1Vlz_VIcbbgwqSg45TFt7lxpK38gaRhBsAcs#_ftnref1, 7.02.2023.

Raymond N. A., Howarth C. (2022), Extrajudicial Detentions and Enforced Disappearences in Kherson Oblast, Conflict Observatory, https://hub.conflictobservatory.org/portal/apps/sites/#/home/pages/kherson-1, 20.11.2022.

Riabchuk M. (2002), Ukraine: One State, Two Countries?, https://www.eurozine.com/ukraine-one-state-two-countries/, 20.03.2023.

Riabchuk M. (2015), Two Ukraines’ Reconsidered: The End of Ukrainian Ambivalence?, “Studies in Ethnicity and Nationalism”, vol. 15, no. 1. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/sena.12120

Schmitter P. (1994), Dangers and Dilemmas of Democracy, “Journal of Democracy”, vol. 5, no. 2. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1353/jod.1994.0036

Shvets K. (2022), World models of post-conflict territories management. Experience for Ukraine, “Political life”, vol. 2.

Social and political thought: the dictionary-reference (2008), eds. Yu. I. Yurystovskyi, Spolom, Lviv.

Sociologists record deterioration of relations between locals and IDPs in Ukraine (2017), https://www.unian.ua/society/1810447-na-sogodni-zniklimi-bezvisti-zalishayutsya-483-ukrajintsya-geraschenko.html, 14.03.2023.

Šabi C. (2007), “Ich erinnere mich nicht, aber L’viv!” Zur Funktion kultureller Faktoren für die Institutionalisierung und Entwicklung einer ukrainischen Region, SPPS 48, Stuttgart.

Uilson A. (1998), National History and National Identity in Ukraine and Belarus, in: Nation Building in Post-Soviet Borderlands. The Politics of National Identity, eds. G. Smit, V. Lou, A. Uilson, A. Bor, E. Olvort, Cambridge University Press.

Victims of Circumstance or Traitors: How Ukrainians View Those Living Under Occupation (2022), https://www.unian.ua/society/zhertvi-obstavin-abo-zradniki-yak-ukrajinci-stavlyatsya-do-tih-hto-zhive-pid-okupaciyeyu-11984523.html, 15.01.2023.

Voronyi M. (1921), Collection of poems “For Ukraine!”, Sons of Ukraine, Warsaw, https://diasporiana.org.ua/wp-content/uploads/books/15774/file.pdf, 10.04.2023.

“We should not dream of the impossible: 90% of refugees will not return to Ukraine” – Director of the Institute of Demography Libanova (2023), https://suspilne.media/381881-ne-varto-mriati-pro-nezdijsnenne-90-bizenciv-ne-povernutsa-v-ukrainu-direktorka-institutu-demografii/, 13.03.2023.

Wilson A. (2002), Elements of a Theory of Ukrainian Ethno-National Identities, “Nations and Nationalism”, vol. 8, no. 1. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/1469-8219.00037

Yale University researchers provide evidence of a “targeted campaign” of terror by Russian forces in Kherson region (2022), https://www.radiosvoboda.org/a/news-viyska-rf-kherson-teror-doslidnyky/32137459.html, 19.01.2023.