Is Separation of Powers a Useless Concept? Part II: Tripartite System Criticism and Application Problems

Main Article Content

Martin Hapla

Abstract

In this paper, the author raised the question of whether the separation of powers is a useless concept. It summarizes some critical arguments against the tripartite separation of powers. The paper deals with application issues related to the separation of powers and distinguishes several attitudes toward them, which it then analyses in more detail. Great attention is dedicated to formalism and functionalism. Eventually, the author wonders whether it would be better to innovate the idea of separation of powers, or to dismiss and replace it with some other principle. He concludes that the separation of powers has problems, but we need to evaluate this idea in relation to its possible alternatives. In such a light it still sounds promising.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

Article Details

How to Cite
Hapla, M. (2020). Is Separation of Powers a Useless Concept? Part II: Tripartite System Criticism and Application Problems. Adam Mickiewicz University Law Review, 9. https://doi.org/10.14746/ppuam.2019.9.14
Section
Articles

References

  1. Baroš J., Dělba moci jako nástroj konstitucionalismu, Jurisprudence 2013, no. 7.
  2. Carolan E., The New Separation of Powers: A Theory for the Modern State, New York 2009.
  3. Claus L., Montesquieu’s Mistakes and the True Meaning of Separation, Oxford Journal of Legal Studies 2005, no. 3.
  4. Cooper S. W., Considering “Power” in Separation of Powers, Stanford Law Review 1994, no. 2.
  5. Fairlie J. A., The Separation of Powers, “Michigan Law Review” 1923, no. 4.
  6. Hamilton, A., Madison, J., Jay J., The Federalist, Indianapolis 2005.
  7. Kurland P. B., The Rise and Fall of the “Doctrine” of Separation of Powers, “Michigan Law Review” 1986, no. 3.
  8. Magill M. E., The Real Separation in Separation of Powers Law, “Virginia Law Review” 2000, no. 6.
  9. Montesquieu Ch., The Spirit of Laws, Kitchener 2001.
  10. Nourse V., The Vertical Separation of Powers, “Duke Law Journal” 1999, no. 3.
  11. Tomoszek M., Dělba moci jako podstatná náležitost demokratického právního státu, in Dělba moci. Sborník příspěvků sekce ústavního práva, přednesených na mezinárodní vědecké konferenci Olomoucké právnické dny 2013, ed. Jirásek, J., Olomouc 2014.
  12. Vile M. J. C., Constitutionalism and the Separation of Powers, Indianopolis 1998.
  13. Waldron J., Political Political Theory. Essays on Institutions, Cambridge–London 2016.
  14. Weyr F., Československé právo ústavní, Praha 1937.
  15. Weyr F. Teorie práva, Praha 2015.
  16. Zoulík F., Soudy a soudnictví, Praha 1995.