The European Union and Fundamental Rights/Human Rights: Vanguard or Villain?

Main Article Content

Allan Rosas


The protection of fundamental rights and human rights in the European Union has witnessed several phases and fluctuations. In the early days of European integration, whilst it would be exaggerated to brand the then Communities a ‘villain,’ there was no explicit recognition of fundamental rights/human rights as being part of Community law. I hope it should have become clear by now that the Union does not fit particularly well into any of these two extremes. But by comparison to the other EU institutions, the Court of Justice has been somewhat of a forerunner, taking the first steps towards a fundamental rights system already in 1969 and contributing in many respects to its further development.


Download data is not yet available.

Article Details



  1. Aalto P. et al., Article 47: Right to an Effective Remedy and to a Fair Trial, in The EU Charter of Fundamental Rights: A Commentary, ed. S. Peers et al., Oxford 2014.
  2. Barnard C., Article 28: Right of Collective Bargaining and Action, in The EU Charter of Fundamental Rights: A Commentary, ed. S. Peers et al., Oxford 2014.
  3. Brandtner B., Rosas A., Human Rights and the External Relations of the European Community: An Analysis of Doctrine and Practice, “European Journal of International Law” 1998, vol. 9.
  4. Brandtner B., Rosas A., Trade Preferences and Human Rights, in The EU and Human Rights, ed. P. Alston, Oxford 1999.
  5. Economic, Social and Cultural Rights: A Textbook, ed. A. Eide, C. Krause, A. Rosas, Dordrecht 2001.
  6. Fundamental Rights Protection of the European Union, ed. J. Barz, Warsaw 2009. Halberstam D., It’s the Autonomy, Stupid!” – A Modest Defense of Opinion 2/13 on EU Accession to the ECHR, and the Way Forward, “Public Law and Legal Theory Research Paper Series,” Paper No. 432.
  7. Kilpatrick C., Article 21: Non-Discrimination, in The EU Charter of Fundamental Rights: A Commentary, ed. S. Peers et al., Oxford 2014.
  8. Morgera E., Marín Durán G., Article 37: Environmental Protection, in The EU Charter of Fundamental Rights: A Commentary, ed. S. Peers et al., Oxford 2014.
  9. O’Brien C., Article 26: Integration of Persons with Disabilities, in The EU Charter of Fundamental Rights: A Commentary, ed. S. Peers et al., Oxford 2014.
  10. Pescatore P., Les droits de l ’homme et l ’intégration européenne, “Cahiers de droit européen” 1968.
  11. Rosas A., Counter-Terrorism and the Rule of Law: Issues of Judicial Control, in Counter-Terrorism: International Law and Practice, ed. A.M Salinas de Frías et al., Oxford 2012.
  12. Rosas A., Fundamental Rights in the Luxembourg and Strasbourg Courts, in The EFTA Court: Ten Years On, ed. C Baudenbacher et al., Oxford 2005.
  13. Rosas A., Is the EU a Human Rights Organisation?, “CLEER Working Papers” no. 1, The Hague 2011.
  14. Rosas A., The Applicability of the EU Charter of Fundamental Rights at National Level, “European Yearbook on Human Rights” 2013, vol. 13.
  15. Rosas A., The Charter and Universal Human Rights Instruments, in The EU Charter of Fundamental Rights: A Commentary, ed. S. Peers et al., Oxford 2014.
  16. Rosas A., The European Court of Justice and Fundamental Rights: Yet Another Case of Judicial Activism?, in European Integration through Interaction of Legal Regimes, ed. C. Baudenbacher, H. Bull, Oslo 2007.
  17. Rosas A., The European Union: In Search of Legitimacy, in 60 Years of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights in Europe, ed. V. Jaichand, M. Suksi, Antwerp 2009.
  18. Rosas A., The European Union and Fundamental Rights/Human Rights’, in International Protection of Human Rights: A Textbook, ed. C. Krause, M. Scheinin, Turku – Åbo 2012.
  19. Rosas A., The European Union and International Human Rights Instruments, in The European Union and the International Legal Order: Discord or Harmony, ed. V. Kronenberger, The Hague 2001.
  20. Rosas A., Armati L., EU Constitutional Law: An Introduction, Oxford 2012.
  21. Rosas A., Kaila H., L’application de la Charte des droits fondamentaux de l ’Union européenne par la Cour de justice : Un premier bilan’, “XVI Il diritto dell’Unione Europea” 2011.
  22. The Court of Justice and the Construction of Europe: Analyses and Perspectives on Sixty Years of Case-law – La Cour de justice et la Construction de l ’Europe: Analyses et Perspectives de Soixante Ans de Jurisprudence, ed. A. Rosas et al., The Hague 2013.
  23. The EU Charter of Fundamental Rights: From Declaration to Binding Instrument, ed. G. Di Federico, Dordrecht 2011.
  24. Thym D., Attack or Retreat? Evolving Themes and Strategies of the Judicial Dialogue between the German Constitutional Court and the European Court of Justice, in Constitutional Conversations in Europe: Actors, Topics and Procedures, ed. M. Claes et al., Cambridge 2012.
  25. Ward A., Article 51: Field of Application, in The EU Charter of Fundamental Rights: A Commentary, ed. S. Peers et al., Oxford 2014.
  26. Weatherhill S., Article 38: Consumer Protection, in The EU Charter of Fundamental Rights: A Commentary, ed. S. Peers et al., Oxford 2014.
  27. Van Gend en Loos 1963-2013: 50ème Anniversaire de l ’arrêt – 50th Anniversary of the Judgment, ed. A. Tizzano et al., Luxembourg 2013.
  28. Case 4/73 Nold v Commission EU:C:1974:51, § 13. Case 6/64 Costa EU:C:1964:66.
  29. Case 11/70 Internationale Handelsgesellschaft EU:C:1970:114, §§ 3-4. Case 26/62 Van Gend & Loos EU:C:1963:1.
  30. Case 29/69 Stauder EU:C:1969:57.
  31. Case C-268/94 Portugal v Council EU:C:1996:461. Case C-279/09 DEB EU:C:2010:811.
  32. Cases C-293/12 Digital Rights Ireland.
  33. Case C-341/05 Laval un Partneri EU:C:2007:809, §§ 90-91. Case C-348/12 P Council v Kala Naft EU:C:2013:776.
  34. Case C-356/12 Glazel EU:C:2014:350. Case C-399/11 Melloni EU:C:2013:107.
  35. Case C-438/05 International Transport Workers’ Federation (‘Viking Line’) EU:C:2007:772
  36. Case C-540/03 Parliament v Council EU:C:2006:429.
  37. Case C-584/10 P Commission and Others v Kadi EU:C:2013:518.
  38. Case C-594/12 Kärntner Landesregierung and Others EU:C:2014:238. Case C-617/10 Åkerberg Fransson EU:C:2013:105.
  39. Case of Goodwin v United Kingdom, Eur.C.H.R., judgment of 11 July 2002 (Application No. 28957/95).
  40. Case of Micallef v Malta, ECHR, judgment of 15 October 2009 (Application No. 17056/06).
  41. Case of Povse v Austria, ECHR judgment of 18 June 2013 (Application No. 3890/11).
  42. Case of Scoppola v Italy, ECHR, judgment of 17 September 2009 (Application No. 10249/03).
  43. Case of Tarakhel v Switzerland, judgment of 4 November 2014 (Application No. 29217/12).
  44. Cases 46/87 and 222/88 Hoechst v Commission EU:C:1989:337. Cases C-148/13 to C-150/13 A, B and C EU:C:2014:2406. Cases C-335/11 and C-337/11 HK Danmark EU:C:2013:222.
  45. Cases C-387/02, C-391/02 and C-404/02 Berlusconi EU:C:2005:270.
  46. Cases C-402/05 P C-415/05 P Kadi and Al Barakaat International Foundation v Council and Commission EU:C:2008:461.
  47. Cases C-411/10 and C-493/10 NS and ME EU:C:2011:865. Constitutional Treaty [2004] OJ C310/1.
  48. Council Directive 2000/78/EC of 27 November 2000 establishing a general framework for equal treatment in employment and occupation [2000] OJ L303/16.
  49. Decision of 7 June 2000, BVerfGE 102, 147.
  50. Decision of 22 October 1986, BVerfGE 73, 339. Decision of 29 May 1974, BVerfGE 37, 271.
  51. Opinion 2/94 Accession to the European Convention on Human Rights EU:C:1996:140.
  52. Opinion 2/13 Draft Accession Agreement ECHR EU:C:2014:2454.
  53. UN Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities [2010] OJ L23/35.