The civil liability of asset managers
PDF (Język Polski)

Keywords

civil liability
brokerage services
asset management
MiFID
harmonisation

How to Cite

Sójka, T. (2017). The civil liability of asset managers. Ruch Prawniczy, Ekonomiczny I Socjologiczny, 79(1), 103–117. https://doi.org/10.14746/rpeis.2017.79.1.8

Number of views: 368


Number of downloads: 210

Abstract

This paper focuses on the civil liability of asset managers under Polish law. Following the transformation of the economic system and the development of the capital market in Poland, the importance of asset management has been gradually increasing, though it remains disproportionally lower when compared to the role of collective asset management in the form of investment funds. The chief purpose of both MiFID directives is to harmonise the rules applicable to investment firms providing brokerage services in Europe, and to protect the interests of investors who use brokerage services. Although the civil liability of investment firms offering brokerage services is part of what is broadly construed as investor protection, the regulations on this matter have been left to the Member States’ discretion. There is no doubt that discrepancies between Member States in this respect diminish the harmonising effect of both directives. This paper aims to determine the basic rules of civil liability of asset managers in Polish law, and present suggestions for the most common problems in this field.
https://doi.org/10.14746/rpeis.2017.79.1.8
PDF (Język Polski)

Funding

National Science Centre Research Grant no. DEC-2013/09/B/HS5/00289

References

Assmann, H.D., Schneider, U.H. (Hrsg.), Wertpapierhandelsgesetz, Köln.

Chłopecki, A. (2006), [w:] Szumański, A. (red.), System Prawa Prywatnego. Prawo papierów wartościowych, t. 19, Warszawa.

Szpunar, A. (1976), [w:] Radwański, Z. (red.), System prawa cywilnego, t. 3, cz. 2, Prawo zobowiązań–część szczegółowa, Wrocław.

Kawecki, A.W. (2012), [w:] D. Busch, D.A. DeMott, Liability of Asset Managers, Oxford.

CESR Level 3 Recommendations on Inducements under MiFID, Cesr/07-316, May 2007 http://www.esma.europa.eu/system/files/07_316.pdf [dostęp:12.03.2015].

Benicke, Ch. (2006), Wertpapiervermögensverwaltung, Tübingen.

Busch, D., DeMott, D.A. (2012), Liability of Asset Managers, Oxford.

Busch, D. (2012), Why MiFID matters to private law—the example of MiFID’s impact on an asset manager’s civil liability, Capital Markets Law Journal 7(4).

DeMott, D.A. (2012), Regulatory techniques and liability regimes for asset managers, Capital Markets Law Journal 7(4).

Pistor, K., Xu, Ch. (2003), Fiduciary duty in transitional civil law jurisdictions lessons from the incomplete law theory, [w:] Milhaupt, C.J. (ed.), Global Markets, Domestic Institutions: Corporate Law and Governance in a New Era of Cross-Border Deals, New York.

Zacharzewski, K. (2015), Szkoda giełdowa i jej naprawienie, Toruń.

Kopaczyńska-Pieczniak, K. (2014), [w:] Kidyba, A. (red.), Kodeks Cywilny. Komentarz, t. 3, wyd. 2, Warszawa.

Enriques, L. (2007), Conflict of interest in Investment Services: The Price and Uncertain Impact of MiFID’s Regulatory Framework [w:] Ferrrarini, G., Wymeersch, E. (eds.), Investor Protection in Europe. Corporate Law Making, The MiFID and Beyond, Oxford.

Casper, M., Altgen, Ch. (2012), [w:] Busch, D., DeMott, D.A., Liability of Asset Managers, Oxford.

Gutowski, M. (2009), Ważność umowy zawartej w zakresie działalności licencjonowanej przez osobę nieposiadającą wymaganej licencji, Monitor Prawniczy 3.

Kaliński, M. (2014), Szkoda na mieniu i jej naprawienie, Warszawa.

Kurzajewski, M. (2014), Usługi maklerskie, Warszawa.

Tison, M. (2010), The civil law effects of MiFID in a comparative law perspective, [w:] Festschrift für Klaus J. Hopt. Unternehmen, Markt ung Verantwortung, Bd. 2, Berlin–New York.

Moloney, N. (2014), EU Securities and Financial Markets Regulation, Oxford.

Moloney, N. (2012), Liability of asset managers: a comment, Capital Markets Law Journal 7(4).

Cherednychenko, O.O. (2010), Full harmonization of Retail Financial Services Contract Law in Europe [w:] S. Grundmann, Y.M. Atamer (red.), Financial Services, Financial Crisis and General European Contract Law.

Machnikowski, P. (2013), [w:] Łętowska, E. (red.), System prawa prywatnego. Prawo zobowiązań – część ogólna, t. 5, wyd. 2, Warszawa.

Mülbert, P.O. (2008), Auswirkungen der art. 19 ff MiFID auf das Zivilrecht am Beispiel von Vertriebsvergütungen im Effektengeschäft der Kreditinstitute, Zeitschrift für das gesamte Handels- und Wirtschaftsrecht 172.

Zapadka, P. (2014), [w:] Wierzbowski, M., Sobolewski, L., Wajda, P., Prawo rynku kapitałowego. Komentarz, wyd. 2, Warszawa.

Mülbert, P.O. (2007), The Eclipse of Contract Law in the Investment Firm-Client Relationship: The Impact of the MiFID on the Law of Contract from a German Perspective, [w:] Ferrrarini, G., Wymeersch, E. (eds.), Investor Protection in Europe. Corporate Law Making, The MiFID and Beyond, Oxford.

Buczek, S. (red.) (2006), Asset Management – zarządzanie aktywami w Polsce, Warszawa.

Möllers, T.M.J. (2007), [w:] Hirte, H., Möllers, T.M.J. (Hrsg.), Kölner Kommentar zum WpHG, Köln–Berlin–München.

Radwański, Z., Olejniczak, A. (2014), Zobowiązania–część ogólna, wyd. 11, Warszawa.