Pressto.

Page Header

The challenges of Holocaust instruction and remembrance - Particular and universal aspects in formal and informal interdisciplinary curricula in Israel and abroad

Nitza Davidovich, Dan Soen, Anat Hezkelovich

DOI: https://doi.org/10.14746/i.2011.15.16.03

Abstract


The challenges of Holocaust instruction and remembrance - Particular and universal aspects in formal and informal interdisciplinary curricula in Israel and abroad


The present article examines Holocaust instruction in Israel and in France, addressing formal and informal aspects of teaching practices. Specifically, the article examines whether Holocaust instruction constitutes a unifying factor that stresses what is common to human beings, among adolescents at schools in Israel and abroad, or whether it is a continuation of the methodic axis of the general model of the school and its credo. The study was conducted as part of a large-scale project evaluating 20 years of journeys to Poland by Israeli youth. It is based on a qualitative research apporoach that included analysis of interviews with policymakers, representatives of Holocaust institutes and foundations, teachers, students and guides. It also made use of field observations and official documents. The qualitative analysis revealed that that the dominant didactic models in Israel and France differ from one another in the importance that they attribute to universal versus the particular elements. Each of the models was built based on a didactic foundation of educational and teaching activity at the school in general, and Holocaust instruction in particular. The study findings indicate that in general, the Holocaust instruction in Israel continues to emphasize the particular. It serves as a tool for strengthening the unique values of the event, and stresses Israeliness, Zionism, and Jewishness. The climax of the modal is an eight-day journey to Poland, centering on a visit to Auschwitz. In contrast, Holocaust instruction in France emphasizes the universal. The curriculum positions the journey as the climax of the scholastic experience but, unlike the Israeli curriculum, it emphasizes the historical and universal aspects of the Holocaust and represses the singularity of the event in the context of the Jewish people. A comparison of the two countries underlines the substantive differences separating the two different educational systems, which have adopted different sets of values.


Keywords


Memorial; Holocaust Teaching; Universalism; Particularism; Holocaust Pilgrimages

Full Text:

References


Carver, R. “Theory for practice: A framework for thinking about experiential education.” The Journal of Experiential Education, 19, 1996. 8-13.

Davidovich, N., and Kendall, Y. “Joint Trips by Israelis and Germans – Beyond the Experiential Upheaval.” Kivunim Hadashim, 14, 2006. 152-164.

Degnen, C. “Relationality, place, and absence: A three-dimensional perspective on social memory.” The Sociological Review, 53, 2005. 729-744.

Don Yehiya, E., and Lieberman, Y. “The Dilemma of Culture in the Modern State: Changes and Developments in Civil Religion in Israel.” Megamot, 28(4), 1984. 461-485.

Fentress, J., and Wickham, C. Social memory. Oxford: Blackwell, 1992.

Golan, Y. To Poland and back in 24 hours. www.zazu.co.il/Article.asp?artId=641 (2005).

Graetz, Z. Chronicles of Israel. Volume 4. Tel Aviv: Jezreel, 1954.

Grossman, H. “The March of the Living.” Kesher Ayin, 147, 2005. 12-14.

Handel, M. (1950). Gzerot Tach Vetat [the Chmelnitsky Massacres of 1648- 1648]. Jerusalem: Kiryat Sefer.

Jablonka, H. (1998). Holocaust survivors in Israel – first summaries. Bshvil Hazikaron, 26. Jerusalem: Yad Vashem, The Central School for Holocaust Studies.

“Jewish teacher in France suspended for teaching ‘too much’ about the Holocaust.” Haaretz, 1/9, 2010.

Knoch, H. “The search for authenticity: Memory, emotions and testimony in today’s Germany.” Tabur, 1, 2008. 10-23.

Lev, M. The efFect of youth journeys to Poland on their positions vis-à-vis the Holocaust in the cognitive domain and in the emotional domain. Master’s thesis. Bar Ilan University, Ramat Gan, 1998.

Resnik, J. “Sites of memory of the Holocaust: Shaping National Memory of the Education System in Israel.” Nations and Nationalism, 9, 2003. 297-317.

Romi, S., and Lev, M. israeli adolescents’ knowledge, emotions and positions vis-à-vis the Holocaust.” Megamot, 42, 2003. 219-239.

Stauber, R. The lesson for the generation – Holocaust and heroism in the minds of the public during the 1950s. Jerusalem: Ben Zvi Institute, 2000.

The Ministry of Education and Culture. Youth journeys to Poland – it is my brothers that I seek,” Director General’s Circular, 2009.

Interview with Fondation de la Shoa-Paris representative Dominique Trimbur, February (2009).

Interview with the director of the Memorial, Jacques Fredj, February (2009).

Interview with Olivier Lalieu, who is in charge of school journeys by students to Poland at Memorial de la Shoah, February (2009).

Interview with Charlotte Le Provost, who is in charge of pedagogical programs at Memorial de la Shoah, February (2009).

Interview with Alexandre Doulout, guide and escort from Memorial de la Shoah, February (2009).

Telephone interview with Alban Perrin, supervisor at Memorial de la Shoah in charge of pedagogical work at schools, February (2009).

Interview with Ariel Sion, director of the library at Memorial de la Shoah, February (2009).

Interview with Henri Nadroast, representative of the French Ministry of Education, February (2009).

Interview with a rectorat [sic] representative from the French Ministry of Education, February (2009).

Interview with a history and philosophy teacher from Cezanne School, on a flight to Poland, February (2009).

Interview with a teacher returning from the journey, February (2009).

Interview with a teacher from a vocational school, February (2009).

Short interview with students from Cezanne School, February (2009).

Observation of a French shareholder’s journey to Poland, February (2009).

Information sheet from the Fondation de la Shoa, Memorial’s partner and subsidizer, on how to teach the subject of the Holocaust.

Hebrew information sheet presenting the Memorial. “Le monde actuel, histoire et civilisation’’, Belin, Paris, 1963.

Jean Francois Boissy, Shoah a l’age democratique quelle enjeux? ed Armand Colin, Paris, 2007.

Dominique Born, Cahiers de la Shoah, no 1, 1993.

Yad Vashem: http://www.yadvashem.org/hp_he.htm

The Memorial de la Shoah in France: http://www.izieu.alma.fr/anglais/frame_principale.htm

PRESSto2AMUR - export

Statystyki

Abstract - 166 PDF (Język Polski) - 143

Altmetric

Refbacks

  • There are currently no refbacks.




Copyright (c) 2015